However, I hardly see which way
your argument tends. I suppose you mean that the papers being
uncorrected and not having undergone a final revising were more easily
falsified by Eusebius. Perhaps I am stupid; but the argument appears to
me somewhat foolish and pointless. If the papers were uncorrected and
had not undergone their final revision, the errors in them must be
imputed not to Eusebius but to your sloth and delay in putting off
their correction; and all the blame that can be laid upon him is that
he circulated among the body of Christians writings which you had
intended in course of time to correct. But if, as you assert, Eusebius
falsified them, why do you put forward the allegation that they were
uncorrected, and that they had gone out before the public without their
final revision? For papers whether corrected or uncorrected are equally
susceptible of falsification. But, No one, you say possessed these
books, or very few. What contradictions this single sentence exhibits!
If no one had these books, how could they be in the hands of a few? If
a few possessed them, why do you state falsely that there were none?
Then, when you say that a few had them, and by your own confession the
statement that no one had them is overthrown, what becomes of your
complaint that your secretary was bribed with money? Tell us the
secretary’s name, the amount of the bribe, the place, the
intermediary, the recipient. Of course the traitor has been cast off
from you,
and one convicted of so great a crime has been separated from all
familiarity with you. Is it not more likely to be true that the copies
of the work which Eusebius obtained were given him by those few friends
whom you speak of, especially since these copies agree and coincide
with one another so completely that there is not the difference of a
single stroke. We might ask also whether it was quite wise to give a
copy to others which you had not yet corrected? The documents had not
received their last corrections, and yet other men possessed these
errors of yours which needed correction. Do you not see that your
falsehood will not hold together? Besides, what profit was there for
you, at that particular moment—how would it have helped you in
escaping from the condemnation of the bishops—that the book which
was the subject of discussion should be open to everyone, and that you
should thus be refuted by your own words? From all this it is clear,
according to the epigram of the famous orator, that you have a good
will for a lie, but not the art of framing it.