Chapter 25.—48. Therapius of Bulla1827 said: "If a man gives up and betrays the baptism
of Christ to heretics, what else can he be said to be but a Judas to the Bride of Christ?"1828
49. How great a condemnation have we here of all schismatics, who have separated
themselves by wicked sacrilege from the inheritance of Christ dispersed throughout the
whole world, if Cyprian held communion with such as was the traitor Judas, and yet was
not defiled by them; or if he was defiled, then were all made such as Judas; or if they were
not, then the evil deeds of those who went before do not belong to those who came after
even though they were the offspring of the same communion. Why, therefore, do they cast
in our teeth the traditores, against whom they did not prove their charge, and do not cast
in their own teeth Judas, with whom Cyprian and his colleagues held communion? Behold
the Council in which these men are wont to boast! We indeed say, that he who approves
the baptism of Christ even in heretics, does not betray to heretics the baptism of Christ; just
in the same way as he does not betray to murderers the baptism of Christ who approves the
baptism of Christ even in murderers: but inasmuch as they profess to prescribe to us from
the decrees of this Council what opinions we ought to hold, let them first assent to it them-
selves. See how therein were compared to the traitor Judas, all who said that heretics, al-
though baptized in heresy, should not be baptized again. Yet with such Cyprian was willing
to hold communion, when he said, "Judging no man, nor depriving any of the right of
communion if he entertain a contrary opinion." But that there had been men of such a sort
in former times within the Church, is made clear by the sentence in which he says: "But
some one will say, What, then, shall be done with these men who in times past were admitted
into the Church without baptism?"1829 That such had been the custom of the Church, is
testified again and again by the very men who compose this Council. If, therefore, any one
who does this "can be said to be nothing else but a Judas to the Bride of Christ," according
to the terms in which the judgment of Therapius is couched; but Judas, according to the
teaching of the gospel, was a traitor; then all those men held communion with traitors who
at that time uttered those very judgments, and before they uttered them they all had become
traitors through that custom which at that time was retained by the Church. All, there-
fore—that is to say, both we and they themselves who were the offspring of that unity—are
traitors. But we defend ourselves in two ways: first, because without prejudice to the right
of unity, as Cyprian himself declared in his opening speech, we do not assent to the decrees
of this Council in which this judgment was pronounced; and secondly, because we hold
that the wicked in no way hurt the good in Catholic unity, until at the last the chaff be sep-
1827 Bulla (Vulla) was in ecclesiastical province of Africa Proconsularis. For Therapius cp. Cypr. Ep. lxiv.
1.
1828 Conc. Carth. sec. 61.
1829 Cypr. Ep. lxxiii. 23.
Chapter 25
945
Chapter 25