41. Here again I am compelled entirely to differ from Stier, who, with Erasmus, Lightfoot, Kuinoel, Schleiermacher, &c., understands this as ironical—‘but ye give alms of their contents, and behold, all things are clean (in your estimation) to you.’But (1) this is inconsistent with the imperative ä ü ô å. (2) It would require ἐκτῶνἐνότων, for the Pharisees did not give τὰἐνόντα in this sense. (3) It would be altogether irrelevant to the matter in hand, which was reproof to the Pharisees for their care about outward cleanliness, when the inside was left unclean. (4) It would be inconsistent with the emphatic position of τὰἐνόντα, which are thus pointed out as the true material, out of which to give alms. It would be altogether contrary to our Lord’s usual habit of speaking about giving alms, to make Him cast a slur on it, as this would do: see Mark 10:21; ch. Luke 12:33, where the expression is very similar to this.
The command is a rebuke for their covetousness (see ch. Luke 16:14), which follows in close connexion with ἁρπαγή and ð ï í ç ñ ß á, Luke 11:39. The τὰἐνόντα are the contents of the vessel, which vessel (Luke 11:39: see note above) is ὑμεῖς: = therefore, in its meaning, the τὰὑπάρχοντα of ch. Luke 12:33,—and the πάντακαθαράἐστιν answers to the θησαυρὸςἐνοὐρανῷ of that verse, the result of which is the καρδίαἐνοὐρανῷ: and such persons being καθαροὶτῇκαρδίᾳ,—to them, as τοῖςκαθαροῖς, ð Ü í ô á ê á è á ñ Ü (Titus 1:15).