It had usually been supposed that these Four Books were
the “quædam capitula” which Charlemagne had sent by
Angelbert to Pope Hadrian “to be corrected by his judgment (ut
illius judicio corrigerentur). Considering the nature of the
contents of the Caroline Books as we now have them, such would seem
à priori highly improbable, but this matter has been
practically settled, as we have already pointed out, by Bishop Hefele,
who has shown from Pope Hadrian’s answer “correcting”
those “capitula,” that they must have been entirely
different in order though no doubt their contents were similar.
The differing views of Petavius and Walch will be found in full in
Hefele (§ 401).