males give birth to abortions, which, being of both sexes, fell on the earth, and lived, and
grew, and came together, and produced offspring. Hence sprang all animal life in earth,
air, and sea.360 Now if the origin of flesh is from heaven, that is no reason for thinking it
especially unclean. Indeed, in this construction of the world, they hold that these principles
of darkness were arranged higher or lower, according to the greater or less amount of good
mixed with them in the construction of the various parts of the world. So flesh ought to be
cleaner than vegetables which come out of the earth, for it comes from heaven. And how
irrational to suppose that the abortions, before becoming animate, were so lively, though
in an abortive state, that after falling from the sky, they could live and multiply; whereas,
172
after becoming animate, they die if brought forth prematurely, and a fall from a very mod-
erate height is enough to kill them! The kingdom of life in contest with the kingdom of
death ought to have improved them, by giving them life instead of making them more per-
ishable than before. If the perishableness is a consequence of a change of nature, it is wrong
to say that there is a bad nature. The change is the only cause of the perishableness. Both
natures are good, though one is better than the other. Whence then comes the peculiar
impurity of flesh as it exists in this world, sprung, as they say, from heaven? They tell us,
indeed, of the first bodies of these principles of darkness being generated like worms from
trees of darkness; and the trees, they say, are produced from the five elements. But supposing
that the bodies of animals come in the first place from trees, and afterwards from heaven,
why should they be more unclean than the fruit of trees? Perhaps it will be said that what
remains after death is unclean, because the life is no longer there. For the same reason fruits
and vegetables must be unclean, for they die when they are pulled or cut. As we saw before,
the elect get others to bring their food to them, that they may not be guilty of murder.
Perhaps, since they say that every living being has two souls, one of the race of light, and
the other of the race of darkness, the good soul leaves at death, and the bad soul remains.
But, in that case, the animal would be as much alive as it was in the kingdom of darkness,
when it had only the soul of its own race, with which it had rebelled against the kingdom
of God. So, since both souls leave at death, why call the flesh unclean, as if only the good
soul had left? Any life that remains must be of both kinds; for some remains of the members
of God are found, we are told, even in filth. There is therefore no reason for making flesh
more unclean than fruits. The truth is, they pretend to great chastity in holding flesh unclean
because it is generated. But if the divine body is more grossly shut in by flesh, there is all
the more reason that they should liberate it by eating. And there are innumerable kinds of
worms not produced from sexual intercourse; some in the neighborhood of Venice come
from trees, which they should eat, since there is not the same reason for their being unclean.
360 [Compare the Introduction, where an abstract is given of the Fihrist’s account of the creation.—A.H.N.]
291
Faustus avows his disbelief in the Old Testament and his disregard of its…