“In all the Scripture from one end to the other, there is recorded but one judgment to con-
demnation, which came upon all men, and that is Gen. iii. 17-19. Dust thou art, ” &c. P. 40.
speaking of the same, he says, ”All men are brought under condemnation.” In p. 27, 28. “By
judgment, judgment to condemnation, it appeareth evidently to me, he (Paul) means the
being adjudged to the forementioned death; he means the sentence of death, of a general
mortality, pronounced upon mankind, in consequence of Adam’s first transgression. And
the condemnation inflicted by the judgment of God, answereth to, and is in effect the same
thing with, being dead.” P. 30. “The many, that is mankind, were subject to death by the
judicial act of God.” P. 31. ” Being made sinners, may very well signify, being adjudged, or
condemned to death.—For the Hebrew word, &c. signifies to make one a sinner by a judicial
sentence, or to condemn.“—P. 178. Par. on Rom. v. 19. “Upon the account of one man’s
disobedience, mankind were judicially constituted sinners; that is, subjected to death, by the
sentence of God the Judge.“—And there are many other places where he repeats the same
thing. And it is pretty remarkable, that (page 48, 49.) immediately after citing Prov. xvii. 15.
“He that justifieth the wicked, and he that condemneth the just, are both an abomination
to the Lord”—and when he is careful in citing these words, to put us in mind, that it is meant
of a judicial act—yet, in the very next words, he supposes that God himself does so, since
he constantly supposes that Adam’s posterity, whom God condemns, are innocent. His
words are these, “From all this it followeth, that as the judgment, that passed upon all men
to condemnation, is death’s coming upon all men, by the judicial act of God, upon the occasion
of Adam’s transgression: so,” &c.—And it is very remarkable that (p. 3, 4, 7. S.) he insists,
“That in Scripture no action is said to be imputed, reckoned, or accounted to any person
for righteousness or condemnation, but the proper act and deed of that person.”—And yet
he thus continually affirms, that all mankind are made sinners by a judicial act of God the
Judge, even to condemnation, and judicially constituted sinners, and so subjected to a judicial
sentence of condemnation, on occasion of Adam’s sin; and all according to the threatening
denounced to Adam, “Thou shalt surely die:” though he supposes Adam’s posterity were
not included in the threatening, and are looked upon as perfectly innoncent, and treated
wholly as such.
I am sensible Dr. T. does not run into all this inconsistence, only through oversight and
blundering; but that he is driven to it, to make out his matters in his evasion of that noted
paragraph in the fifth chapter of Romans; especially those three sentences; (Rom. v. 16.)
“The judgment was by one to condemnation.” (Rom. v. 18.) “By the offence of one, judgment
came upon all men to condemnation;” and (Rom. v. 19.) “By one man’s disobedience many
184
were made sinners.” And I am also sensible of what he offers to salve the inconvenience,
viz. “That if the threatening had immediately been executed on Adam, he would have had
no posterity; and that so far the possible existence of Adam’s posterity fell under the
threatening of the law, and into the hands of the judge, to be disposed of as he should think
1039
SECTION III. Adam a federal head, &c.