hastily improvised1121 for the use of the nation. And there is a1122 passage in the Prophet
which confirms this. For he says, “when he came out of the land of Egypt he heard a strange
language1123.” If, then, Moses was a Hebrew, and the language of the Hebrews was subsequent
to the others, Moses, I say, who was born some thousands of years after the Creation of the
world, and who relates the words of God in his own language—does he not clearly teach us
that he does not attribute to God such a language of human fashion, but that he speaks as
he does because it was impossible otherwise than in human language to express his meaning,
though the words he uses have some Divine and profound significance?
For to suppose that God used the Hebrew tongue, when there was no one to hear and
understand such a language, methinks no reasonable being will consent. We read in the
Acts that the Divine power divided itself into many languages for this purpose, that no one
of alien tongue might lose his share of the benefit. But if God spoke in human language before
the Creation, whom was He to benefit by using it? For that His speech should have some
adaptation to the capacity of the hearers, with a view to their profit, no one would conceive
to be unworthy of God’s love to man, for Paul the follower of Christ knew how to adapt his
words suitably to the habits and disposition of his hearers, making himself milk for babes
and strong meat for grown men1124. But where no object was to be gained by such use of
1121 hastily improvised. But Origen, c. Celsum iii. 6, says—“Celsus has not shewn himself a just critic of the
differing accounts of the Egyptians and the Jews.…He does not see that it was not possible for so large a number
of rebellious Egyptians, after starting off in this way, to have changed their language at the very moment of their
insurrection, and so become a separate nation, so that those who one day spoke Egyptian suddenly spoke a
complete Hebrew dialect. Allow for a moment that when they left Egypt they rejected also their mother tongue;
how was it that, thereupon, they did not adopt the Syrian or Phœnician, but the Hebrew which was so different
from both these?…For the Hebrew had been their national language before they went down into Egypt:” And,
i. 16—“I wonder how Celsus can admit the Odrysians amongst the most ancient as well as the wisest peoples,
but will admit the Jews into neither, notwithstanding that there are many books in Egypt and Phœnicia and
Greece which testify to their antiquity. Any one who likes can read Flavius Josephus’ two books on the antiquity
of the Jews, where he makes a large collection of writers who witness to this.” And yet, iii. 7, he goes on to say
(what Gregory is here alluding to) that while any way the Hebrew language was never Egyptian, “yet if we look
deeper, we might find it possible to say in the case of the Exodus that there was a miracle: viz. the whole mass
of the Hebrew people receiving a language; that such language was the gift of God, as one of their own prophets
has expressed it, ‘when he came out of Egypt, he heard a strange language.’”
1122 καί τις. This reading (and not the interrogative τίς, as Oehler) is required by the context, where Gregory
actually favours this theory of the lateness of the Hebrew tongue: and is confirmed by Gretser’s Latin, “Et nescio
quis Prophetæ sermo.”
1123 Ps. lxxxi. 5.
1124 Heb. v. 12.
522
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.