LETTER XLVIII. 75
tude. He makes, also, many other state-
ments, which he has followed up at length in
his three books " On Virgins." 15. From all which considerations it is
clear that I have said nothing at all new
concerning virginity and marriage, but have
followed in all respects the judgment of
older writers — of Ambrose, that is to say, and others who have discussed the doctrines
of the Church. " And I would sooner follow them in their faults than copy the dull
pedantry of the writers of to-day." Let married men, if they please, swell with rage
because I have said,2 " I ask you, what kind of good thing is that which forbids a man
to pray, and which prevents him from re-
ceiving the body of Christ?" When I do my duty as a husband, I cannot fulfil the re-
quirements of continence. The same apos-
tle, in another place, commands us to pray
always.3 " But if we are always to pray we must never yield to the claims of wedlock,
for, as often as I render her due to my wife,
I incapacitate myself for prayer." When I spoke thus it is clear that I relied on the
words of the apostle : " Defraud ye not one the other, except it be with consent for a
time, that ye may give yourselves to . . .
prayer."4 The Apostle Paul tells us that when we have intercourse with our wives we
cannot pray. If, then, sexual intercourse
prevents what is less important — that is,
prayer — how much more does it prevent
what is more important — that is, the recep-
tion of the body of Christ ? Peter, too, ex-
horts us to continence, that our " prayers be
not hindered."6 How, I should like to know, have I sinned in all this? What have
I done? How have I been in fault? If the
waters of a stream are thick and muddy, it
is not the river-bed which is to blame, but the source. Am I attacked because I have
ventured to add to the words of the apostle
these words of my own : " What kind of good thing is that which prevents a man from re-
ceiving the body of Christ?" If so, I will make answer briefly thus: Which is the
more important, to pray or to receive Christ's
body? Surely to receive Christ's body. If, then, sexual intercourse hinders the less im-
portant thing, much more does it hinder that
which is the more important.
I have said in the same treatise6 that
David and they that were with him could
not have lawfully eaten the shew-bread had
they not made answer that for three days
1 Ter. Andria Prol. 20, 21.
3 i Th. v. 17.
6 i Pet. Hi. 7.
2 Ag. Jov. i. 7.
4 i Cor. vii. 5.
6 Ag. Jov. i. 20,
they had not been defiled with women1— not, of course, with harlots, intercourse with
whom was forbidden by the law, but with
their own wives, to whom they were lawfully
united. Moreover, when the people were about to receive the law on Mount Sinai
they were commanded to keep away from
their wives for three days.2 I know that at Rome it is customary for the faithful always
to receive the body of Christ, a custom
which I neither censure nor indorse. " Let
every man be fully persuaded in his own
mind." But I appeal to the consciences of those persons who after indulging in sexual
intercourse on the same day receive the
communion — having first, as Persius puts it,
" washed off the night in a flowing stream," ' and I ask such why they do not presume
to approach the martyrs or to enter the
churches.5 Is Christ of one mind abroad
and of another at home ? What is unlaw-
ful in church cannot be lawful at home.
Nothing is hidden from God. "The night
shineth as the day " before Him.6 Let each man examine himself, and so let him ap-
proach the body of Christ.7 Not, of course, that the deferring of communion for one
day or for two makes a Christian any the
holier or that what I have not deserved to-
day I shall deserve to-morrow or the day
after. But if I grieve that I have not shared
in Christ's body it does help me to avoid
for a little while my wife's embraces, and to prefer to wedded love the love of Christ. A
hard discipline, you will say, and one not to be borne. What man of the world could
bear it ? He that can bear it, I reply, let
him bear it;8 he that cannot must look to himself. It is my business to say, not what
each man can do or will do, but what the
Scriptures inculcate.
16. Again, objection has been taken to
my comments on the apostle in the following
passage:* " But lest any should suppose from the context of the words before quoted
(namely, 'that ye may give yourselves . . .
to prayer and come together again ') that
1 i Sam. xxi. 4, 5. a Ex. xix. 15.
3 Rom. xiv. 5. 4 Pers. ii. 16.
5 That what is now known as reservation of the elements was
practised in the early church there is abundant evidence to show.
Justin Martyr (Apol. I. 65) writes: " The deacons communicate each of those present and carry away to the absent of the blest
bread and wine and water." And those to whom the eucharist was thus taken were not bound to consume it immediately, or all
at once, but might reserve a part or all for future occasions. Ac-
cording to Basil (Ep. 93), " in Egypt the laity for the most part
had every one the communion in their own nouses " — and "all those who dwell alone in the desert, when there is no priest, keep
the communion at home and receive it at their own hands. ' So
Diet, of Christian Antiquities.
6 Ps. cxxxix. n, 12. 7 Cf. i Cor. xi. 28.
8 Cf. Matt. xix. 12. 9 Against Jov. i. 8.