This is substantially what
Theodoret says again and again. This satisfied Cyril. This would
probably have been accepted by Nestorius too. In
Walch’s Hist. Ketz. V. 778, there is a good summary of
Nestorius’ views: he thinks the dispute a mere logomachy. So also
Luther, and after him Basnage, Dupin, Jablonski. Vide reff. in Gieseler
i. 236.
What then was it, apart from the odium theologicum, which kept
Nestorius and Cyril apart? Below the apparent special pleading and
word-jugglery on the surface of the controversy lay the principle that
in the Christ God and man were one; the essence of the atonement or
reconciliation lying in the complete union of the human and the divine
in the one Person; the “I” in the “I am” of the
Temple and the “I thirst” of the Cross being really the
same. “God and man is one Christ.” The position which the
Cyrillians viewed with alarm was a reduction of this unity to a mere
partnership or alliance;—God dwelling in Jesus of Nazareth as He
dwells in all good men, only to a greater degree;—the eternal
Word being in close contact with the son of Mary (συνάφεια). So, whatever may have been the unhappy faction-fights
with which the main issue was confused there was in truth a great
crisis, a great question for decision; was Jesus of Nazareth an unique
personality, or only one more in the goodly fellowship of prophets? Was He God,
or was He not? There can be little doubt as to the answer Nestorius
would have given. There can be none as to that of Theodoret. But on the
part of Cyril there was the quite mistaken conviction that Theodoret
was practically contending for two Christs. On the other hand Theodoret
erroneously identified Cyril with the confusion of the substance and
practical patripassianism which he scathes in the
“Eranistes,” and which the common sense of Christendom has
condemned in Eutyches.