The fourth book is obviously the
most important, as treating of heresies of which the writer would have
contemporary knowledge. And special interest has attached to the
chapter on Nestorius, who is condemned not merely for erroneous opinion
on the incarnation and person of Christ, but as a timeserver and
pretender, seeking rather to be thought, than to be, a Christian.
Garnerius indeed doubts the genuineness of the chapter, and Schulze, in
defending it, points out the similarity of its line of argument to that
employed in the treatise “against Nestorius,” which is very
generally regarded as spurious. It may have been added after Chalcedon,
when the writer had been forced into the denunciation of his old
friend. But the expressions used alike of the incarnation and of
Nestorius seem somewhat in contrast with other writings of Theodoret.
Schröckh xviii. 416. inclines to the view in which
Ceillier concurs, that this damning account of Nestorius was really
written by his old champion, and accounts for the harshness of
condemnation by the influence of the clamours of Chalcedon and the
induration which old age sometimes brings on tender spirits. It can
only be said that if this is Theodoret, it is Theodoret at his
worst.