CLXXX.
Letter of Theodoretus, as some suppose, to Domnus, Bishop of Antioch,
written on the Death of Cyril, Bishop of Alexandria. This letter is inserted in the Act. Synod. (vide Mans. ix. 295) as
addressed to John, but Garnerius, with general acceptance, has
substituted Domnus. Its genuineness was contested by Baronius (an. vi.
23) not only on the ground of its ascription to John who predeceased
Cyril four years; but also because its expressions are at once too
Nestorian in doctrine and too extreme in bitterness to have been penned
by Theodoret. Garnerius is of opinion that the extreme Nestorianism and
bitterness of feeling are no arguments against the authorship of
Theodoret; and, as we have already had occasion to notice, our author
can on occasion use very strong language, as for instance in Letter CL.
p. 324, where he alludes to Cyril as a shepherd not only plague smitten
himself but doing his best to inflict more damage on his flock than
that caused by beast of prey, by infecting his charge with his
disease.
“It must be needless to
add that Cyril’s character is not to be estimated aright by
ascribing any serious value to a coarse and ferocious invective against
his memory, which was quoted as Theodoret’s in the fifth General
Council (Theodor. Ep. 180; see Tillemont, xiv. 784). If it were indeed
the production of the pen of Theodoret, the reputation which would
suffer from it would assuredly be his own.” Canon Bright. Dict.
Christ. Biog. I.
“The long and
bitter controversy in which both parties did and said many things they
must have had cause deeply to regret, was closed by the death of Cyril,
June 9, or 27, 444. With Baronius, ‘the cautious’
Tillemont, Cardinal Newman and Dr. Bright, we should be glad to
‘utterly scout’ the idea, that the ‘atrocious
letter’ on Cyril’s death ascribed to Theodoret by the Fifth
Œcumenical Council (Theod. ed. Schulze, Ep. 180; Labbe, v. 507)
which he was said to have delivered by way of pæan (Bright u. s.
176) and ‘the scarcely less scandalous’ sermon (ib.) can
have been written by him. ‘To treat it as genuine would be to
vilify Theodoret.’ ‘The Fathers of the Council’
writes Dr. Newman ‘are no authority on such a matter’
(Hist. Sketches p. 359). A painful suspicion of their genuineness,
however, still lingers and troubles our conception of Theodoret. The
documents may have been garbled, but the general tone too much
resembles that of undisputed polemical writings of Theodoret’s to
allow us entirely to repudiate them. We wish we could. Neander (vol.
iv. p. 13, note, Clark’s tr.) is inclined to accept the
genuineness of the letter, the arguments against which he does not
regard as carrying conviction, and to a large extent deriving their
weight from Tillemont’s ‘Catholic standpoint.’ That
Theodoret should speak in this manner of Cyril’s character and
death cannot, he thinks, appear surprising to those who, without
prejudice, contemplate Cyril and his relations to Theodoret. The
playful description, after the manner of Lucian, of a voyage to the
Shades below, is not to be reckoned a very sharp thing even in
Theodoret. The advice to put a heavy stone over his grave to keep Cyril
down is sufficient proof that the whole is a bitter jest. The world
felt freer now Cyril was gone; and he does not shrink from telling a
friend that he could well spare him. ‘The exaggeration of
rhetorical polemics requires many grains of allowance.’”
Canon Venables. Dict. Christ. Biog. iv.