All was now ready; the creed, the result of
minute and careful deliberations (we do not know their history, nor even how long they
occupied The
events have been related in what seems to be their most likely order,
but there is no real certainty in the matter. It is clear that there
were at least two public sittings (Soz. i. 17, the language of Eus.
V. C. iii. 10, is reconcileable with this) in the
emperor’s presence, at the first of which the libelli were
burned and the bishops requested to examine the question of faith. This
was probably on June 19. The tearing up of the creed of Eus. Nic. seems
from the account of Eustathius to have come immediately before the
final adoption of a creed. The creed of Eusebius of Cæsarea, which
was the basis of that finally adopted, must therefore have been
propounded after the failure of his namesake. (Montfaucon and others
are clearly wrong in supposing that this was the
‘blasphemy’ which was torn to pieces!) The difficulty is,
where to put the dramatic scene of whisperings, nods, winks, and
evasions which compelled the bishops to apply a drastic test. I think
(with Kölling, &c.) that it must have preceded the proposal of
Eusebius, upon which the ὁμοούσιον was quietly insisted on by Constantine; for the latter was
the only occasion (πρόφασις) of any modification in the Cæsarean Creed, which in
itself does not correspond to the tests described infr. p. 163.
But Montfaucon and others, followed by Gwatkin, place the scene in
question after the proposal of Eus. Cæs. and the resolution
to modify his creed by the insertion of a stringent test,—in fact
at the ‘pause’ of the council before its final resolution.
This conflicts with the clear statement of Eusebius that the
ὁμοούσιον was the ‘thin end of the wedge’ which led to the
entire recasting of his creed (see infr. p. 73. The idea of
Kölling, p. 208, that the creed of Eusebius was drawn up by him
for the occasion, and that the μάθημα of
the council was ready beforehand as an alternative document, is refuted
by the relation of the two documents; see Hort, pp. 138, 139). It
follows, therefore, from the combined accounts of Ath., Euseb. and
Eustathius (our only eye-witnesses) that (1) the fathers were
practically resolved upon the ὁμοούσιον before the final sitting. (2) That this resolve was clinched
by the creed of Eusebius of Nicomedia. (3) That Eusebius of
Cæsarea made his proposal when it was too late to think of
half-measures. (4) That the creed of Eusebius was modified at the
Emperor’s direction (which presupposes the willingness of the
Council). (5) That this revision was immediately followed by the
signatures and the close of the council. The work of revision, however,
shews such signs of attention to detail that we are almost compelled to
assume at least one adjournment of the final sitting. When the other
business of the council was transacted, including the settlement of the
Easter question, the Meletian schism, and the Canons, it is impossible
to say. Kölling suo jure puts them at the first public
session. The question must be left open, as must that of the presidency
of the council. The conduct of the proceedings was evidently in the
hands of Constantine, so that the question of presidency reduces itself
to that of identifying the bishop on Constantine’s right who
delivered the opening address to the Emperor: this was certainly not
Hosius (see Vit. C. iii. 11, and vol. 1 of this series, p. 19),
but may have been Eusebius of Cæsarea, who probably after a few
words from Eustathius (Thdt.) or Alexander (Theod. Mops. and Philost.)
was entrusted with so congenial a task. The name of Hosius stands first
on the extant list of signatures, and he may have signed first,
although the lists are bad witnesses. The words of Athanasius sometimes
quoted in this connection (p. 256), ‘over what synod did he not
preside?’ must be read in connection with the distinction made by
Theodoret in quoting the passage in question (H. E. ii. 15) that
Hosius ’was very prominent at the great synod of
Nicæa, and presided over those who assembled at Sardica.
This is the only evidence we possess to which any weight can be
attached.), lay before the council. We are told
‘the council paused.’ The evidence fails us; but it may
well have been so. All the bishops who were genuinely horrified at the
naked Arianism of Eusebius of Nicomedia were yet far from sharing the
clearsighted definiteness of the few: they knew that the test proposed
was not in Scripture, that it had a suspicious history in the Church.
The history of the subsequent generation shews that the mind of Eastern
Christendom was not wholly ripe for its adoption. But the fathers were
reminded of the previous discussions, of the futility of the Scriptural
tests, of the locust and the caterpillar, of the whisperings, the nods,
winks, and evasions. With a great revulsion of feeling the council
closed its ranks and marched triumphantly to its conclusion. All
signed,—all but two, Secundus and Theonas. Maris signed and
Theognis, Menophantus and Patrophilus, and all the rest. Eusebius of
Nicomedia signed; signed everything, even the condemnation of his own
convictions and of his ‘genuine fellow-Lucianist’ Arius;
not the last time that an Arian leader was found to turn against a
friend in the hour of trial. Eusebius justified his signature by a
‘mental reservation;’ but we can sympathise with the bitter
scorn of Secundus, who as he departed to his exile warned Eusebius that
he would not long escape the same fate (Philost. i. 9).