juries, frauds, massacres, assassinations they have either heard of, or read in history; thence
concluding all mankind to be very wicked. As if a court of justice were a proper place to
make an estimate of the morals of mankind, or an hospital of the healthfulness of a climate.
But ought they not to consider, that the number of honest citizens and farmers far surpasses
that of all sorts of criminals in any state, and that the innocent and kind actions of even
criminals themselves surpass their crimes in numbers; that it is the rarity of crimes, in
comparison of innocent or good actions, which engages our attention to them, and makes
them to be recorded in history, while honest, generous domestic actions are overlooked,
only because they are so common? as one great danger, or one month’s sickness, shall become
a frequently repeated story during a long life of health and safety.—Let not the vices of
mankind be multiplied or magnified. Let us make a fair estimate of human life, and set over
against the shocking, the astonishing instances of barbarity and wickedness that have been
perpetrated in any age, not only the exceeding generous and brave actions with which history
shines, but the prevailing innocency, good-nature, industry, felicity, and cheerfulness of the
greater part of mankind at all times; and we shall not find reason to cry out, as objectors
against Providence do on this occasion, that all men are vastly corrupt, and that there is
hardly any such thing as virtue in the world. Upon a fair computation, the fact does indeed
come out, that very great villanies have been very uncommon in all ages, and looked upon
as monstrous; so general is the sense and esteem of virtue.”—It seems to be with a like view
that Dr. Taylor says, “We must not take the measure of our health and enjoyments from a
lazar-house, nor of our understanding from Bedlam, nor of our morals from a gaol.” (P. 77.
S.)
With respect to the propriety and pertinence of such a representation of things, and its
147
force as to the consequence designed, I hope we shall be better able to judge, and in some
measure to determine, whether the natural disposition of the hearts of mankind be corrupt
or not, when the things which follow have been considered. But for the greater clearness, it
may be proper here to premise one consideration, that is of great importance in this contro-
versy, and is very much overlooked by the opposers of the doctrine of original sin in their
disputing against it.
That it is to be looked upon as the true tendency of the innate disposition of man’s heart,
which appears to be its tendency, when we consider things as they are in themselves, or in
their own nature, without the interposition of divine grace. Thus, that state of man’s nature,
that disposition of the mind, is to be looked upon as evil and pernicious, which, as it is in
itself, tends to extremely pernicious consequences, and would certainly end therein, were
it not that the free mercy and kindness of God interposes to prevent that issue. It would be
very strange if any should argue, that there is no evil tendency in the case, because the mere
favour and compassion of the Most High may step in and oppose the tendency, and prevent
the sad effect. Particularly, if there be any thing in the nature of man, whereby he has an
935
SECTION I. All men tend to sin and ruin.