This anonymous work against the heresy of Artemon is no longer
extant, and the only fragments of it which we have are those preserved
by Eusebius in this chapter. Theodoret (Hær. Fab. II. 5)
mentions the work, and says that it was directed against the heresies
of Theodotus and Artemon, and that it bore the name Little
Labyrinth. It is plain, from the fragments which Eusebius gives,
that it was written in Rome some little time before the middle of the
third century, probably not far from 230 or 240 a.d. The work is commonly ascribed to Hippolytus, in favor
of which may be urged both the time and the place of its composition as
well as some internal resemblance between it and the
Philosophumena. On the other hand, Photius (Cod. 48)
ascribes to Caius of Rome a work against Artemon, which may well be
identical with the anonymous work quoted in the present chapter. It is
therefore contended by some (e.g. by Salmon) that Caius was the author
of the work. It must be noted, however, that in the same connection
Photius ascribes another work to Caius which we know to have been
written by Hippolytus, and hence his testimony is rather in favor of
Hippolytus than Caius as the author of the work. On the other hand
several objections have been urged by Salmon against the Hippolytine
authorship, which, while not decisive, yet make it extremely doubtful.
In view of these facts, we must conclude that it is possible, but very
improbable, that Hippolytus wrote the work; that it is not impossible,
though we are quite without evidence for the supposition, that Caius
wrote it; that it is more likely that a work which even to Eusebius was
anonymous, was written by an unknown man, who must remain unknown to us
also. The extant fragments of the work are given, with notes, by Routh
in his Rel. Sac., and an English translation in the
Ante-Nicene Fathers, Vol. V. p. 601 sq., among the works of
Caius. Although the work is said by Eusebius to have been directed
against the heresy of Artemon, he has preserved only extracts relating
to the Theodoti and their heresy. They are described also by
Hippolytus, both in his lost Syntagma (as we can learn from
Pseudo-Tertullian, Epiphanius, and Philaster) and in his
Philosophumena (VII. 23–24, and X. 19). Other ancient
writers that mention him know only what our anonymous author or
Hippolytus reports. It seems that the older Theodotus, a native of
Byzantium, came to Rome in the time of Eleutherus or Victor, and taught
a species of adoptionism, which reminds us somewhat of the Asia Minor
Alogi, in whose circle he may have been trained. Hippolytus informs us
that he was orthodox in his theology and cosmology, but that he was
heretical in his Christology. He did not deny Christ’s birth from
a virgin (as the Ebionites had done), but he did deny his divinity,
teaching that he was a mere man (ψιλὸς
ἄνθρωπος), upon whom the Holy Spirit descended at the time of his baptism,
in consequence of which he became the Christ, received power to fulfill
his special mission and by his righteousness was raised above all other
men. The descent of the Holy Spirit, however, although raising him to a
very exalted position, did not make him divine; some of
Theodotus’ followers denying that he ever acquired divinity,
others believing that he acquired it by his resurrection. Theodotus was
excommunicated by Victor on account of his heretical Christology, but
gained a number of followers, and after his excommunication founded a
schismatical sect, which had a bishop Natalius, to whom a regular
salary was paid (see below, §10), and which continued under the
leadership of another Theodotus, a banker, and a certain Asclepiodotus,
both of them disciples of the first Theodotus, during the episcopate of
Zephyrinus, but seems soon to have disappeared, and to have exerted
comparatively little influence during its brief existence. Theodotus,
the banker, appears to have agreed substantially with the older
Theodotus, but to have indulged himself in speculations concerning
Melchizedek, pronouncing him to be a heavenly power still higher than
Christ. Epiphanius makes the second Theodotus the founder of a second
party, and gives his school the name of Melchizedekians, which appears
in later works on heresy, but there is no reason to suppose that there
were two separate parties.
A few years later
another attempt was made in Rome to revive the old adoptionist
Christology (essentially the same as that represented by Hermas early
in the second century), by a certain Artemon, against whom the
Little Labyrinth, quoted in this chapter, was directed. It is
common to connect Artemon and his followers with the Theodotians; but,
as Harnack remarks, it is plain that they did not look upon themselves
as the followers of the Theodoti (see below, note 15). We cannot tell,
however, in what respect their Christology differed from that of the
latter, for we know very little about them. They at any rate agreed
with the Theodotians in denying the divinity of Christ. From the
epistle of the synod of Antioch (quoted below, in Bk. VII. chap. 30) we
learn that Artemon was still living in the year 268, or thereabouts. He
seems, however to have accomplished little in Rome, and to have dropped
into comparative obscurity some time before this; at least, we hear
nothing of him during all these years. In the controversy with Paul of
Samosata he was called the father of the latter (see below Bk. VII.
chap. 30, §16), and thus acquired considerable celebrity in the
East, where his name became permanently connected with that of Paul as
one of the leading heretics. Whether Paul really learned his
Christology from Artemon we do not know, but that it closely resembled
that of the latter there can be no doubt. He really reproduced the old
adoptionist Christology of Hermas (as both the Theodotians and Artemon
had done), but modified it under the influence partly of Origen’s
teachings, partly of the Aristotelian method. For further particulars
in regard to the Theodoti and Artemon, see the remaining notes on this
chapter. For an admirable discussion of the whole subject, see
Harnack’s Dogmengeschichte, I. p. 573 sq. On the Little
Labyrinth, see especially the Dict. of Christian Biog. III.
p. 98.