The above witnesses, all of whom excepting No.
viii. come within 50 years of the death of Athanasius, are a formidable
array. No other work of Athanasius can boast of such external evidence
in its favour. And in the face of such evidence it is impossible to
place the composition later than the lifetime of the great Bishop. We
have therefore to ask whether the contents of the Vita are in
irreconcileable conflict with the result of the external evidence:
whether they point, not indeed to a later age, for the external
evidence excludes this, but to an author who during the lifetime of
Athanasius (i.e. not later than the year of his death) ventured to
publish a hagiographic romance in his name (‘Evagrian’
heading, and §§71, 82).