2. I write this after reading the memoranda
submitted by your piety, which I could wish had not been written at
all, so that not even any record of these things should go down to
posterity. For who ever yet heard the like? Who ever taught or learned
it? For ‘from Sion shall come forth the law of God, and the word
of the Lord from Jerusalem Isa. ii. 3; Mic. iv.
2.;’ but whence
came forth this? What lower region has vomited the statement that the
Body born of Mary is coessential with the Godhead of the Word? or that
the Word has been changed into flesh, bones, hair, and the whole body,
and altered from its own nature? Or who ever heard in a Church, or even
from Christians, that the Lord wore a body putatively, not in nature;
or who ever went so far in impiety as to say and hold, that this
Godhead, which is coessential with the Father, was circumcised and
became imperfect instead of perfect; and that what hung upon the tree
was not the body, but the very creative Essence and Wisdom? Or who that
hears that the Word transformed for Himself a passible body, not of
Mary, but of His own Essence, could call him who said this a Christian?
Or who devised this abominable impiety, for it to enter even his
imagination, and for him to say
that to pronounce the Lord’s Body to be of Mary is to hold a
Tetrad instead of a Triad in the Godhead? Those who think thus, saying
that the Body of the Saviour which He put on from Mary, is of the
Essence of the Triad. Or whence again have certain vomited an impiety
as great as those already mentioned; saying namely, that the body is
not newer than the Godhead of the Word, but was coeternal with it
always, since it was compounded of the Essence of Wisdom. Or how did
men called Christians venture even to doubt whether the Lord, Who
proceeded from Mary, while Son of God by Essence and Nature, is of the
seed of David according to the flesh Rom. i. 3., and of the
flesh of the Holy Mary? Or who have been so venturesome as to say that
Christ Who suffered in the flesh and was crucified is not Lord,
Saviour, God, and Son of the Father This
opinion seems to belong to that next to be mentioned, the two, however,
are separately dealt with below, cc. 10 and 11.? Or how can
they wish to be called Christians who say that the Word has descended
upon a holy man as upon one of the prophets, and has not Himself become
man, taking the body from Mary; but that Christ is one person, while
the Word of God, Who before Mary and before the ages was Son of the
Father, is another? Or how can they be Christians who say that the Son
is one, and the Word of God another?