was, when He was doing?” “By no means. There is no necessity for His being changed, when
He makes the world from what He was when He was not making it; and neither is there any
necessity for saying that the universe must have co-existed with Him, on account of our not
being forced to say that He has changed, nor that the universe is co-eternal with Him.”
IV. But speak to me thus: “Should you call that a thing created which had no beginning
of its creation?” “Not at all.” “But if there is no beginning of its creation, it is of necessity
uncreated. But if it was created, you will grant that it was created by some cause. For it is
altogether impossible that it should have a beginning without a cause.” “It is impossible.”
“Shall we say, then, that the world and the things which are in it, having come into existence
and formerly not existing, are from any other cause than God?” “It is plain that they are
from God.” “Yes; for it is impossible that that which is limited by an existence which has a
beginning should be co-existent with the infinite.” “It is impossible.” “But again, O Centaur,
let us consider it from the beginning. Do you say that the things which exist were created
by Divine knowledge or not?” “Oh, begone, they will say; not at all.” “Well, but was it from
the elements, or from matter, or the firmaments, or however you choose to name them, for
it makes no difference; these things existing beforehand uncreated and borne along in a
state of chaos; did God separate them and reduce them all to order, as a good painter who
forms one picture out of many colours?” “No, nor yet this.” For they will quite avoid making
a concession against themselves, lest agreeing that there was a beginning of the separation
and transformation of matter, they should be forced in consistency to say, that in all things
God began the ordering and adorning of matter which hitherto had been without form.
V. But come now, since by the favour of God we have arrived at this point in our dis-
course; let us suppose a beautiful statue standing upon its base; and that those who behold
it, admiring its harmonious beauty, differ among themselves, some trying to make out that
it had been made, others that it had not. I should ask them: For what reason do you say that
it was not made? on account of the artist, because he must be considered as never resting
from his work? or on account of the statue itself? If it is on account of the artist, how could
it, as not being made, be fashioned by the artist? But if, when it is moulded of brass, it has
all that is needed in order that it may receive whatever impression the artist chooses, how
can that be said not to be made which submits to and receives his labour? If, again, the statue
is declared to be by itself perfect and not made, and to have no need of art, then we must
allow, in accordance with that pernicious heresy, that it is self-made. If perhaps they are
unwilling to admit this argument, and reply more inconsistently, that they do not say that
the figure was not made, but that it was always made, so that there was no beginning of its
being made, so that artist might be said to have this subject of his art without any beginning.
Well then, my friends, we will say to them, if no time, nor any age before can be found in
the past, when the statue was not perfect, will you tell us what the artist contributed to it,
or wrought upon it? For if this statue has need of nothing, and has no beginning of existence,
854
Extracts from the Work on Things Created.