96
avoid the nonsense of those arrogant philosophers who do not blush to liken their soul to
that of a dog; who say that they have been formerly themselves women, shrubs, fish.1648
Have they ever been fish? I do not know; but I do not fear to affirm that in their writings
they show less sense than fish. “Let the earth bring forth the living creature.” Perhaps many
of you ask why there is such a long silence in the middle of the rapid rush of my discourse.
The more studious among my auditors will not be ignorant of the reason why words fail
me. What! Have I not seen them look at each other, and make signs to make me look at
them, and to remind me of what I have passed over? I have forgotten a part of the creation,
and that one of the most considerable, and my discourse was almost finished without
touching upon it. “Let the waters bring forth abundantly the moving creature that hath life
and fowl that may fly above the earth in the open firmament, of heaven.”1649 I spoke of
fish as long as eventide allowed: to-day we have passed to the examination of terrestrial
animals; between the two, birds have escaped us. We are forgetful like travellers who un-
mindful of some important object, are obliged, although they be far on their road, to retrace
their steps, punished for their negligence by the weariness of the journey. So we have to
turn back. That which we have omitted is not to be despised. It is the third part of the an-
imal creation, if indeed there are three kinds of animals, land, winged and water.
“Let the waters” it is said “bring forth abundantly moving creature that hath life and fowl
that may fly above the earth in the open firmament of heaven.” Why do the waters give birth
also to birds? Because there is, so to say, a family link between the creatures that fly and
those that swim. In the same way that fish cut the waters, using their fins to carry them
forward and their tails to direct their movements round and round and straightforward, so
we see birds float in the air by the help of their wings. Both endowed with the property of
swimming, their common derivation from the waters has made them of one family.1650 At
the same time no bird is without feet, because finding all its food upon the earth it cannot
1648 Empedocles is named as author of the lines: ἤδη γὰρ ποτ᾽ ἐγὼ γενόμην κούρητε κόρος τε, Θάμνος τ᾽
οἰωνός τε καὶ εἰν ἁλὶ ἔλλοπος ἰχθύς cf. Diog. Laert. viii. 78, and Plutarch, D Solert. An. ii. 964. Whether the
“faba Pythagoræ cognata” of Hor., Sat. ii. 6, 63, implies the transmigration of the soul into it is doubtful. cf.
Juv., Sat. xv. 153. Anaximander thought that human beings were originally generated from fish. Plut., Symp.
viii. 8.
1649 Gen. i. 20.
1650 Fialon quotes Bossuet, 1st Elev. 5th week: “Qui a donné aux oiseaux et aux poissons ces rames naturelles,
qui leur font fendre les eaux et les airs? Ce qui peut être a donné lieu à leur Créateur de les produire ensemble,
comme animaux d’un dessin à peu près semblable: le vol des oiseaux semblant, etre une espèce de faculté de nager
dans une liqueur plus subtile, comme la faculté de nager dans les poissons est une espèce de vol dans une liqueur
plus épaisse.” The theory of evolutionists is, as is well known, that birds developed out of reptiles and reptiles
from fish. Vide E. Haeckel’s monophyletic pedigree in his History of Creation.
334
The creation of fowl and water animals.