I think, she replied, that the
Gospel signifies by means of each of them certain doctrines with regard
to our question of the soul. For when the patriarch first says to the
Rich Man, “Thou in thy lifetime receivedst thy good
things,” and in the same way speaks of the Poor Man, that he,
namely, has done his duty in bearing his share of life’s evil
things, and then, after that, adds with regard to the gulf that it is a
barrier between them, he evidently by such expressions intimates a very
important truth; and, to my thinking, it is as follows. Once
man’s life had but one character; and by that I mean that it was
to be found only in the category of the good and had no contact with
evil. The first of God’s commandments attests the truth of this;
that, namely, which gave to man unstinted enjoyment of all the
blessings of Paradise, forbidding only that which was a mixture of good
and evil and so composed of contraries, but making death the penalty
for transgressing in that particular. But man, acting freely by a
voluntary impulse, deserted the lot that was unmixed with evil, and
drew upon himself that which was a mixture of contraries. Yet Divine
Providence did not leave that recklessness of ours without a
corrective. Death indeed, as the fixed penalty for breaking the law,
necessarily fell upon its transgressors; but God divided the life of
man into two parts, namely, this present life, and that “out of
the body” hereafter; and He placed on the first a limit of the
briefest possible time, while He prolonged the other into eternity; and
in His love for man He gave him his choice, to have the one or the
other of those things, good or evil, I mean, in which of the two parts
he liked: either in this short and transitory life, or in those endless
ages, whose limit is infinity. Now these expressions “good”
and “evil” are equivocal; they are used in two senses, one
relating to mind and the other to sense; some classify as good whatever
is pleasant to feeling: others are confident that only that which is
perceptible by intelligence is good and deserves that name. Those,
then, whose reasoning powers have never been exercised and who have
never had a glimpse of the better way soon use up on gluttony in this
fleshly life the dividend of good which their constitution can claim,
and they reserve none of it for the after life; but those who by a
discreet and sober-minded calculation economize the powers of living
are afflicted by things painful to sense here, but they reserve their
good for the succeeding life, and so their happier lot is lengthened
out to last as long as that eternal life. This, in my opinion, is the
“gulf”; which is not made by the parting of the earth, but
by those decisions in this life which result in a separation into
opposite characters. The man who has once chosen pleasure in this life,
and has not cured his inconsiderateness by repentance, places the land
of the good beyond his own reach; for he has dug against himself the
yawning impassable abyss of a necessity that nothing can break through.
This is the reason, I think, that the name of Abraham’s bosom is
given to that good situation of the soul in which Scripture makes the
athlete of endurance repose. For it is related of this patriarch first,
of all up to that time born, that he exchanged the enjoyment of the
present for the hope of the future; he was stripped of all the
surroundings in which his life at first was passed, and resided amongst
foreigners, and thus purchased by present annoyance future blessedness.
As then figuratively ἐκ
καταχρήσεώς
τινος: not as usually
“by a misuse of words.” we call a
particular circuit of the ocean a “bosom,” so does
Scripture seem to me to express the idea of those measureless blessings
above by the word “bosom,” meaning a place into which all
virtuous voyagers of this life are, when they have put in from hence,
brought to anchor in the waveless harbour of that gulf of blessings There
is an anacoluthon here, for τῷ ἀγάθῳ
κόλπῳ follows
ᾧ above;
designed no doubt to bring the things compared more closely together.
Oehler, however, would join ἀγάθῳ with the
relative, and translates as if τῷ = καί.. Meanwhile the denial of these blessings
which they witness becomes in the others a flame, which burns the soul
and causes the craving for the refreshment of one drop out of that
ocean of blessings wherein the saints are affluent; which nevertheless
they do not get. If, too, you consider the
“tongue,” and the “eye,” and the
“finger,” and the other names of bodily organs, which occur
in the conversation between those disembodied souls, you will be
persuaded that this conjecture of ours about them chimes in with the
opinion we have already stated about the soul. Look closely into the
meaning of those words. For as the concourse of atoms forms the
substance of the entire body, so it is reasonable to think that the
same cause operates to complete the substance of each member of the
body. If, then, the soul is present with the atoms of the body when
they are again mingled with the universe, it will not only be cognizant
of the entire mass which once came together to form the whole body, and
will be present with it, but, besides that, will not fail to know the
particular materials of each one of the members, so as to remember by
what divisions amongst the atoms our limbs were completely formed.
There is, then, nothing improbable in supposing that what is present in
the complete mass is present also in each division of the mass. If one,
then, thinks of those atoms in which each detail of the body
potentially inheres, and surmises that Scripture means a
“finger” and a “tongue” and an
“eye” and the rest as existing, after dissolution, only in
the sphere of the soul, one will not miss the probable truth. Moreover,
if each detail carries the mind away from a material acceptation of the
story, surely the “hell” which we have just been speaking
of cannot reasonably be thought a place so named; rather we are there
told by Scripture about a certain unseen and immaterial situation in
which the soul resides. In this story of the Rich and the Poor Man we
are taught another doctrine also, which is intimately connected with
our former discoveries. The story makes the sensual pleasure-loving
man, when he sees that his own case is one that admits of no escape,
evince forethought for his relations on earth; and when Abraham tells
him that the life of those still in the flesh is not unprovided with a
guidance, for they may find it at hand, if they will, in the Law and
the Prophets, he still continues entreating that Just τὸν
δίκαιον.
Most of Krabinger’s Codd. read τὸν
πλούσιον. Patriarch, and asks that a sudden and
convincing message, brought by some one risen from the dead, may be
sent to them.