II. His remarks on the relation
between the ideal and the actual Man are very interesting. It is usual
with the other Fathers, in speaking of man’s original perfection,
to take the moment of the first man’s residence in Paradise, and
to regard the whole of human nature as there represented by the
first two human beings. Gregory is far removed from this way of looking
at the matter. With him human perfection is the ‘idea’ of
humanity: he sees already in the bodily-created Adam the fallen man.
The present man is not to be distinguished from that bodily Adam; both
fall below the ideal type. Gregory seems to put the Fall beyond and
before the beginning of history. ‘Under the form of narrative
Moses places before us mere doctrine Or.
Cat. c. viii. D..’ The
locus classicus about the idea and the reality of human nature
is On the Making of Man, I. p. 88f. He sketches both in a
masterly way. He speaks of the division of the human race into male and
female as a ‘device’ (ἐπιτέχνησις), implying that it was not the first
‘organization’ (κατασκευή). He hints that the irrational element was actually
provided by the Creator, Who foresaw the Fall and the Redemption, for
man to sin in; as if man immediately upon the creation of the perfect
humanity became a mixed nature (spirit and flesh), and his fall was not
a mere accident, but a necessary consequence of this mixed
nature. Adam must have fallen: there was no perfect humanity in
Paradise. In man’s mixed nature of spirit and flesh nutrition is
the basis of his sensation, and sensation is the basis of his thought;
and so it was inevitable that sin through this lower yet vital side of
man should enter in. So ingrained is the spirit with the flesh in the
whole history of actual humanity that all the varieties of all the
souls that ever have lived or ever shall, arise from this very mixture;
i.e. from the varying degrees of either factor in each. But as
Gregory’s view here touches, though in striking contrast, on
Origen’s, more will be said about it in the next
chapter.