164
of the Son “admits these names for itself”; and thinks that, so long as he harangues as if he
were in some gathering of topers, his knavery in dealing with doctrine will not be detected
by any one. For in joining “product of generation” with “product of making,” and “product
of creation,” he thinks that he stealthily makes away with the difference in significance
between the names, by putting together what have nothing in common. These are his clever
tricks of dialectic; but we mere laymen in argument650 do not deny that, so far as voice and
tongue are concerned, we are what his speech sets forth about us, but we allow also that our
ears, as the prophet says, are made ready for intelligent hearing. Accordingly, we are not
moved, by the conjunction of names that have nothing in common, to make a confusion
between the things they signify: but even if the great Apostle names together wood, hay,
stubble, gold, silver, and precious stones651, we reckon up summarily the number of things
he mentions, and yet do not fail to recognize separately the nature of each of the substances
named. So here, too, when “product of generation” and “product of making” are named
together, we pass from the sounds to the sense, and do not behold the same meaning in
each of the names; for “product of creation” means one thing, and “product of generation”
another: so that even if he tries to mingle what will not blend, the intelligent hearer will
listen with discrimination, and will point out that it is an impossibility for any one nature
to “admit for itself” the appellation of “product of generation,” and that of “product of cre-
ation.” For, if one of these were true, the other would necessarily be false, so that, if the thing
were a product of creation, it would not be a product of generation, and conversely, if it
were called a product of generation, it would be alienated from the title of “product of cre-
ation.” Yet Eunomius tells us that the essence of the Son “admits for itself the appellations
of ‘product of generation,’ ‘product of making,’ and ‘product of creation’”!
Does he, by what still remains, make at all more secure this headless and rootless state-
ment of his, in which, in its earliest stage, nothing was laid down that had any force with
regard to the point he is trying to establish? or does the rest also cling to the same folly, not
deriving its strength from any support it gets from argument, but setting out its exposition
of blasphemy with vague details like the recital of dreams? He says (and this he subjoins to
what I have already quoted)—“Having its generation without intervention, and preserving
indivisible its relation to its Generator, Maker, and Creator.” Well, if we were to leave alone
the absence of intervention and of division, and look at the meaning of the words as it stands
by itself, we shall find that everywhere his absurd teaching is cast upon the ears of those
whom he deceives, without corroboration from a single argument. “Its Generator, and
650 This phrase seems to be quoted from Eunomius. The reference to the “prophet” may possibly be suggested
by Is. vi. 9–10: but it is more probably only concerned with the words ὠτία and ἀκοὴν, as applied to convey the
idea of mental alertness.
651 Cf. 1 Cor. iii. 12.
314
He then exposes argument about the “Generate,” and the “product of making,”…