5. Since you hold to the divine authorship of the Old as well as of the New Testament,
334
it would surely be more consistent and more becoming, as you do not obey its precepts, to
confess that it has been corrupted by improper additions, than to treat it so contemptuously,
if it is genuine and uncorrupted. Accordingly, my explanation of your neglect of the require-
ments of the Old Testament has always been, and still is, that you are either wise enough to
reject them as spurious, or that you have the boldness and irreverence to disregard them if
they are true. At any rate, when you would oblige me to believe everything contained in
the documents of the New Testament because I receive the Testament itself, you should
consider that, though you profess to receive the Old Testament, you in your heart disbelieve
many things in it. Thus, you do not admit as true or authoritative the declaration of the
Old Testament, that every one that hangeth on a tree is accursed,1035 for this would apply
to Jesus; or that every man is accursed who does not raise up seed in Israel,1036 for that
would include all of both sexes devoted to God; or that whoever is not circumcised in the
flesh of his foreskin will be cut off from among his people,1037 for that would apply to all
Christians; or that whoever breaks the Sabbath must be stoned to death;1038 or that no mercy
should be shown to the man who breaks a single precept of the Old Testament. If you really
believe these things as certainly enjoined by God, you would, in the time of Christ, have
been the first to assail Him, and you would now have no quarrel with the Jews, who, in
persecuting Christ with heart and soul, acted in obedience to their own God.
6. I am aware that instead of boldly pronouncing these passages spurious, you make
out that these things were required of the Jews till the coming of Jesus; and that now that
He is come, according, as you say, to the predictions of this Old Testament, He Himself
teaches what we should receive, and what we should set aside as obsolete. Whether the
prophets predicted the coming of Jesus we shall see presently. Meanwhile, I need say no
more than that if Jesus, after being predicted in the Old Testament, now subjects it to this
sweeping criticism, and teaches us to receive a few things and to throw over many things,
in the same way the Paraclete who is promised in the New Testament teaches us what part
of it to receive, and what to reject; as Jesus Himself says in the Gospel, when promising the
Paraclete, "He shall guide you into all truth, and shall teach you all things, and bring all
things to your remembrance."1039 So then, with the help of the Paraclete, we may take the
same liberties with the New Testament as Jesus enables you to take with the Old, unless you
suppose that the Testament of the Son is of greater value than that of the Father, if it is really
1035 Deut. xxi. 23.
1036 Deut. xxv. 5-10.
1037 Gen. xvii. 14.
1038 Num. xv. 35.
1039 John xvi. 13, xiv. 26.
570
Faustus fails to understand why he should be required either to accept or…