But perhaps, in answer to this,
he will again put forth his accustomed logic, and will say that the
same Being is both slave and Lord, dominated by the controlling power
but lording it over the rest. These profound distinctions are talked of
at the cross-roads, circulated by those who are enamoured of falsehood,
who confirm their idle notions about the Deity by illustrations from
the circumstances of ordinary life. For since the occurrences of this
world give us examples of such arrangements Oehler’s punctuation seems here to require
alteration. (thus
in a wealthy establishment one may see the more active and devoted
servant set over his fellow-servants by the command of his master, and
so invested with superiority over others in the same rank and station),
they transfer this notion to the doctrines concerning the Godhead, so
that the Only-begotten God, though subject to the sovereignty of His
superior, is no way hindered by the authority of His sovereign in the
direction of those inferior to Him. But let us bid farewell to such
philosophy, and proceed to discuss this point according to the measure
of our intelligence. Do they confess that the Father is by nature Lord,
or do they hold that He arrived at this position by some kind of
election? I do not think that a man who has any share whatever of
intellect could come to such a pitch of madness as not to acknowledge
that the lordship of the God of all is His by nature. For that which is
by nature simple, uncompounded, and indivisible, whatever it happens to
be, that it is throughout in all its entirety, not becoming one thing
after another by some process of change, but remaining eternally in the
condition in which it is. What, then, is their belief about the
Only-begotten? Do they own that His essence is simple, or do they
suppose that in it there is any sort of composition? If they think that
He is some multiform thing, made up of many parts, assuredly they will
not concede Him even the name of Deity, but will drag down their
doctrine of the Christ to corporeal and material conceptions: but if
they agree that He is simple, how is it possible in the simplicity of
the subject to recognize the concurrence of contrary attributes? For
just as the contradictory opposition of life and death admits of no
mean, so in its distinguishing characteristics is domination
diametrically and irreconcilably opposed to servitude. For if one were
to consider each of these by itself, one could not properly frame any
definition that would apply alike to both, and where the definition of
things is not identical, their nature also is assuredly different. If
then the Lord is simple and uncompounded in nature, how can the
conjunction of contraries be found in the subject, as would be the case
if servitude mingled with lordship? But if He is acknowledged to be
Lord, in accordance with the teaching of the saints, the simplicity of
the subject is evidence that He can have no part or lot in the opposite
condition: while if they make Him out to be a slave, then it is idle
for them to ascribe to Him the title of lordship. For that which is
simple in nature is not parted asunder into contradictory attributes.
But if they affirm that He is one, and is called the other, that He is
by nature slave and Lord in name alone, let them boldly utter this
declaration and relieve us from the long labour of answering them. For
who can afford to be so leisurely in his treatment of inanities as to
employ arguments to demonstrate what is obvious and unambiguous? For if
a man were to inform against himself for the crime of murder, the
accuser would not be put to any trouble in bringing home to him by
evidence the charge of blood-guiltiness. In like manner we shall no
longer bring against our opponents, when they advance so far in
impiety, a confutation framed after examination of their case. For he
who affirms the Only-begotten to be a slave, makes Him out by so saying
to be a fellow-servant with himself: and hence will of necessity arise
a double enormity. For either he will despise his fellow-slave and deny
the faith, having shaken off the yoke of the lordship of Christ, or he
will bow before the slave, and, turning away from the self-determining
nature that owns no Lord over it, will in a manner worship himself
instead of God. For if he sees himself in slavery, and the object of
his worship also in slavery, he of course looks at himself, seeing the
whole of himself in that which he worships. But what reckoning can
count up all the other mischiefs that necessarily accompany this
pravity of doctrine? For who does not know that he who is by nature a
slave, and follows his avocation under the constraint imposed by a
master, cannot be removed even from the emotion of fear? And of this
the inspired Apostle is a witness, when he says, “Ye have not
received the spirit of bondage again to fear Rom. viii. 15..” So that they will be found to
attribute, after the likeness of men, the emotion of fear also to their
fellow-servant God.