that which teaches the universality of the Church are anathema. That doctrine is in Matt.
xxiv. 14, Gen. xii. 3, Gal. iii. 16. The true ordo is the Roman, which he gives from Peter to
Anastasius, the cotemporary pope; no Donatist is found in this list; yet as Montenses and
Cutzupitæ, they have intruded into Rome. Had there been an actual tradition, or any wicked
man in the Church, that would not have vitiated the ordo, or the Church, for the law of
Christ is plain, Matt. xxiii. 3, a passage again and again quoted by Augustin to substantiate
this thought. They are separated from the peace of these very churches, concerning which
they read in their codices, and sing pax tecum. There follows a very full and notable summary
of the acts, as a refutation of the schism. He prefers the Scriptural proofs, which certify to
the world-wide reach of Christ’s inheritance, and its existence among all nations; from this
they are separated by a nefarious schism, and charge upon the Catholics the crimes of the
chaff on the threshing-floor, which must be mixed with the grain until the winnowing; these
accusations do not affect the wheat which grows with the tares in the field until the end.
Their divinely appointed retribution is in the history of the Maximianists, with whom they
now commune, and affirm that they are not stained thereby; let them apply that lenity of
judgment to the inheritance of Christ. The angel then was either Satan, or the man is
Satanic, yet his salvation is desired; the sharp writing concerning him is without odium,
and seeks only his correction.
380
Celer was a Donatist, a man of middle age and of considerable estate and civil position.
He afterwards rose to the proconsulship. Augustin expresses (Ep. lvi.) a peculiar respect
and affection for him, as a man of integrity and seriousness. He had desired direct instruction
from the bishop, both in a matter of Christian culture and in the controversies between the
two parties. Weighed down with the cares of visitation, Augustin had to delegate his pres-
byter Optatus to the reading and explanations of the bishop’s works and views in Celer’s
leisure hours. The superior claims of the life beyond are set before him, together with the
overwhelming force of the proofs against the schism, so that the dullest with patience and
attention can get correction. The sundering of the bonds of custom and of a perversity that
has become familiar, is a matter requiring great strength of character, for which step however,
he, under God, would be readily capable.
But Celer was not persuaded to change his church connection by this first endeavor.
On the contrary, Augustin thought he saw a laxity in the enforcement of the repressive
measure ordered by the government, and so wrote a second time (Ep. lvii.). He affirms that
there is no just cause for separation from that Catholic church which prophets and evangelist
have declared should be diffused through the whole world. A long retained codex of Au-
gustin, which had been loaned to Celer through Cæcilian, his own son, who seems to have
been under the special tutelage of the bishop, was designed to convince the state official on
this very point (we do not know which writing it may have been), should inclination or
leisure lead him to its perusal, and whatever difficulties might occur, Augustin was ready
657
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.