Chapter 34.—39. Petilianus quotes also the warning of the Apostle John, that we should
not believe every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God,2396 as though this care
613
should be bestowed in order that the wheat should be separated from the chaff in this present
world before its time, and not rather for fear that the wheat should be deceived by the chaff;
or as though, even if the lying spirit should have said something that was true, it was to be
denied, because the spirit whom we should abominate had said it. But if any one thinks
this, he is mad enough to contend that Peter ought not to have said, "Thou art the Christ,
the Son of the living God,"2397 because the devils had already said something to the same
effect.2398 Seeing, therefore, that the baptism of Christ, whether administered by an unright-
eous or a righteous man, is nothing but the baptism of Christ what a cautious man and
faithful Christian should do is to avoid the unrighteousness of man, not to condemn the
sacraments of God.
40. Assuredly in all these things Petilianus gives no answer to the question, If the con-
science of one that gives in holiness is what we look for to cleanse the conscience of the re-
cipient, by what means is he to be cleansed who receives baptism, when the conscience of
the giver is polluted without the knowledge of the proposed recipient? A certain Cyprian,
a colleague of his from Thubursicubur, was caught in a brothel with a woman of most
abandoned character, and was brought before Primianus of Carthage, and condemned.
Now, when this man baptized before he was detected and condemned, it is manifest that
he had not the conscience of one that gives in holiness, so as to cleanse the conscience of
the recipient. By what means then have they been cleansed who at this day, after he has
been condemned, are certainly not washed again? It was not necessary to name the man
save only to prevent Petilianus from repeating, "Who is the man, and from what corner has
he started up, that you propose to us?" Why did not your party examine that baptizer, as
John, in the opinion of Petilianus, was examined? Or was the real fact this, that they ex-
amined him so far as man can examine man, but were unable to find him out, as he long
lay hid with cunning falseness?
2396 1 John iv. 1.
2397 Matt. xvi. 16.
2398 Matt. viii. 29; Mark i. 24; Luke viii. 28.
Chapter 34
1220
Chapter 34