Chapter XI.—Further Remarks Upon St. Paul’s Teaching.
Grant, now, that you marry “in the Lord,” in accordance with the law and the apostle—if,
notwithstanding, you care even about this—with what face do you request (the solemnizing
of) a matrimony which is unlawful to those of whom you request it; of a monogamist bishop,
of presbyters and deacons bound by the same solemn engagement, of widows whose Order
you have in your own person refused? And they, plainly, will give husbands and wives as
they would morsels of bread; for this is their rendering of “To every one who asketh thee
thou shalt give!” 662 And they will join you together in a virgin church, the one betrothed
of the one Christ! And you will pray for your husbands, the new and the old. Make your
election, to which of the twain you will play the adulteress. I think, to both. But if you have
any wisdom, be silent on behalf of the dead one. Let your silence be to him a divorce, already
endorsed in the dotal gifts of another. In this way you will earn the new husband’s favour,
if you forget the old. You ought to take more pains to please him for whose sake you have
not preferred to please God! Such (conduct) the Psychics will have it the apostle approved,
68
or else totally failed to think about, when he wrote: “The woman is bound for such length
of time as her husband liveth; but if he shall have died, she is free; whom she will let her
marry, only in the Lord.” 663 For it is out of this passage that they draw their defence of the
licence of second marriage; nay, even of (marriages) to any amount, if of second (marriage):
for that which has ceased to be once for all, is open to any and every number. But the sense
in which the apostle did write will be apparent, if first an agreement be come to that he did
not write it in the sense of which the Psychics avail themselves. Such an agreement, moreover,
will be come to if one first recall to mind those (passages) which are diverse from the passage
in question, when tried by the standard of doctrine, of volition, and of Paul’s own discipline.
For, if he permits second nuptials, which were not “from the beginning,” how does he affirm
that all things are being recollected to the beginning in Christ? 664 If he wills us to iterate
conjugal connections, how does he maintain that “our seed is called” in the but once married
Isaac as its author? How does he make monogamy the base of his disposition of the whole
Ecclesiastical Order, if this rule does not antecedently hold good in the case of laics, from
whose ranks the Ecclesiastical Order proceeds? 665 How does he call away from the enjoy-
ment of marriage such as are still in the married position, saying that “the time is wound
up,” if he calls back again into marriage such as through death had escaped from marriage?
If these (passages) are diverse from that one about which the present question is, it will be
agreed (as we have said) that he did not write in that sense of which the Psychics avail
662 See Matt. v. 42; Luke vi. 30. Comp. de Bapt., c. xviii.
663 1 Cor. vii. 39, not rendered with very strict accuracy.
664 See c. v. above.
665 See de Ex. Cast., c. vii.
Further Remarks Upon St. Paul's Teaching.
154
Further Remarks Upon St. Paul's Teaching.