STUDENT LIFE—PAST
state his grievance particularly to one member of the apprehen-
sive group, who presently said, " I am very sorry, Prof. Swan,
to find that you think I was at the bottom of that disturbance."
At once came the joyous and crushing reply, "I don't think you
were at the bottom of it, but I am very certain you were at the
top of it." Musical himself, he had no difficulty in detecting
a voice otherwise familiar, and in his satisfaction at his success
he instantly closed the episode without the slightest reference to
any but the one offender. Long years afterwards the culprit
and his generous accuser rejoiced together over the recollection
of this and other things that they had in common from their
University experiences.
Outside their classes the students of those days had a variety
of interests. With regard to Sunday there was fitful and gentle
supervision, but absolutely no constraint. On Saturday evenings
the Classical and the Literary Society attracted their respective
members, and provided abundant opportunities for stimulating
oratorical powers that have since been notably exercised in the
pulpit, on the platform, and in Parliament. Other smaller
and special societies furnished separate and peculiar attractions.
After the draughty cloisters were transformed into rooms, some-
where about 1864, opportunity was provided for the practice of
gymnastics, to which a fair number of enthusiasts readily devoted
themselves, largely encouraged in their zeal by the advice and
the expert example of Professor Campbell. The triennial election
of the Lord Rector was invariably a stirring event, sharpening
wits and provoking strong and vehement party discussion.
At a meeting connected with one of these elections a casual
student, fresh from some rural retreat, definitely revealed him
self. Making an appeal in the whirling turmoil to a senior
neighbour, he anxiously asked for a definition of a motion,
pathetically adding,
" I dinna ken what they mean be't a'."
Whether in the end he voted for Froude or Disraeli it is
309