The Church seeks for secular support, and in so doing
insults Christ by the implication that his support is
insufficient. She in her turn holds out the threat of exile and
prison. It was her endurance of these that drew men to her; now
she imposes her faith by violence. She craves for favours at the
hands of her communicants; once it was her consecration that she braved
the threatenings of persecutors. Bishops in exile spread the
Faith; now it is she that exiles bishops. She boasts that the
world loves her; the world’s hatred was the evidence that she was
Christ’s. The ruin is obvious which has fallen upon the
Church. The time of Antichrist, disguised as an angel of light,
has come. The true Christ is hidden from almost every mind and
heart. Antichrist is now obscuring the truth that he may assert
falsehood hereafter. Hence the conflicting opinions of the time,
the doctrine of Arius and of his heirs, Valens, Ursacius, Auxentius and
their fellows. Their preaching of novelties concerning Christ is
the work of Antichrist, who is using them to introduce his own
worship. This is proved (§ 6) by a statement of their
minimising and prevaricating doctrine, which has, however, made no
impression upon the guileless and well-meaning laity. Then
(§§ 7–9) comes Hilary’s account of his
proceedings at Milan, strongly coloured by the intensity of his
feelings. The Emperor’s first refusal to interfere with
Auxentius is a ‘command that the Church of the Milanese, which
confesses that Christ is true God, of one divinity and substance with
the Father, should be thrown into confusion under the pretext, and with
the desire, of unity.’ The canons of Rimini are described
as those of the Thracian Nicæa; Auxentius’ protest that he
had never known Arius is met by the assertion that he had been ordained
to the presbyterate in an Arian Church under George of
Alexandria. Hilary refuses to discuss the Council of Rimini; it
had been universally and righteously repudiated. His ejection
from Milan, in spite of his protests that Auxentius was a liar and a
renegade, is a revelation of the mystery of ungodliness. For
Auxentius (§§ 10, 11) had spoken with two contrary voices;
the one that of the confession which Hilary had driven him to sign, the
other that of Rimini. His skill in words could deceive even the
elect, but he had been clearly exposed. Finally (§ 12)
Hilary regrets that he cannot state the case to each bishop and Church
in person. He begs them to make the best of his letter; he dares
not make it fully intelligible by circulating with it the Arian
blasphemies which he had assailed. He bids them beware of
Antichrist, and warns against love and reverence for the material
structure of their churches, wherein Antichrist will one day have his
seat. Mountains and woods and dens of beasts and prison and
morasses are the places of safety; in them some of the Prophets had
lived, and some had died. He bids them shun Auxentius as an angel
of Satan, an enemy of Christ, a deceiver and a blasphemer.
‘Let him assemble against me what synods he will, let him
proclaim me, as he has often done already, a heretic by public
advertisement, let him direct, at his will, the wrath of the mighty
against me; yet, being an Arian, he shall be nothing less than a devil
in my eyes. Never will I desire peace except with them who,
following the doctrine of our fathers at Nicæa, shall make the
Arians anathema and proclaim the true divinity of Christ.’