This, however, does not please
our new dogmatist. He opposes the arrangement of Scripture. He
separates off that equality with the Father and the Son of His proper
and natural rank and connexion which our Lord Himself pronounces, and
numbers Him with ‘subjects’: he declares Him to be a work
of both Persons he
declares Him to be a work of both Persons. With regard to Gregory’s own belief as to the procession of
the Holy Spirit, it may be said once for all that there is hardly
anything (but see p. 99, note 5) clear about it to be found in his
writings. The question, in fact, remained undecided until the 9th
century, the time of the schism of the East and West. But here, as in
other points, Origen had approached the nearest to the teaching of the
West: for he represents the procession as from Father and Son, just as
often as from one Person or the other. Athanasius does certainly say
that the Spirit ‘unites the creation to the Son, and through the
Son to the Father,’ but with him this expression is not followed
up: while in the Roman Church it led to doctrine. For why does the Holy
Spirit unite the creation with God continuously and perfectly? Because,
to use Bossuet’s words, “proceeding from the Father and the
Son He is their love and eternal union.” Neither Basil, nor
Gregory Nazianzen, nor Chrysostom, have anything definite about the
procession of the Third Person., of the Father, as
supplying the cause of His constitution, of the Only-begotten, as of
the artificer of His subsistence: and defines this as the ground of His
‘subjection,’ without as yet unfolding the meaning of
‘subjection.’