does not agree with real fact, 170 is not agreeable to strict philosophic truth, 171 is contradict-
ory to the truth of things, 172 and which truth contradicts, 173 not tallying with the real plan:
174 and that therefore such feelings are deceitful, 175 and are in reality of the delusive kind,
176 He speaks of them as a wise delusion, 177 as nice artificial feelings, merely that conscience
may have a commanding power: 178 meaning, plainly, that these feelings are a cunning ar-
tifice of the Author of nature, to make men believe they are free, when they are not. 179 He
supposes that, by these feelings, the moral world has a disguised appearance, 180 &c. He
supposes that all self-approbation, and all remorse of conscience, all commendation or
condemnation of ourselves or others, all sense of desert, and all that is connected with this
way of thinking, all the ideas which at present are suggested by the words ought, should,
arise from this delusion, and would entirely vanish without it. 181
All which is very contrary to what I have abundantly insisted on and endeavoured to
demonstrate in my Inquiry; where I have largely shown, that it is agreeable to the natural
sense of mankind, that the moral necessity or certainty that attends men’s actions, is consist-
ent with praise and blame, reward and punishment; 182 and that it is agreeable to our natural
notions, that moral evil, with its desert of dislike and abhorrence, and all its other ill-de-
servings, consists in a certain deformity in the nature of the dispositions and acts of the
heart, and not in the evil of something else, diverse from these supposed to be their cause
or occasion. 183
I might well ask here, whether any one is to be found in the world of mankind, who is
conscious to a sense or feeling, naturally and deeply rooted in his mind, that, in order to a
man’s performing any action that is praiseworthy or blameworthy, he must exercise a liberty
that implies and signifies a power of acting without any motive, view, design, desire, or
170 P. 200.
171 P. 152.
172 P. 183.
173 P. 186.
174 P. 205.
175 P.203, 204, 211.
176 P. 183.
177 P. 209.
178 P. 211.
179 P. 153.
180 P. 214.
181 P. 160, 194, 199, 205, 206, 207, 210.
182 P. Inquiry Part IV. Sect. 4. throughout.
183 Idem. Part IV. Sect. 1. throughout.
773
SECTION XV. Containing Remarks on the Essays on the Principles of Morality…