The
objection is this, that, if our Lord be the Father’s Image, He
ought to resemble Him in being a Father. S. Athanasius answers that God
is not as man; with us a son becomes a father because our nature
is ῥευστὴ,
transitive and without stay, ever shifting and passing on into new
forms and relations; but that God is perfect and ever the same, what He
is once that He continues to be; God the Father remains Father, and God
the Son remains Son. Moreover men become fathers by detachment and
transmission, and what is received is handed on in a succession;
whereas the Father, by imparting Himself wholly, begets the Son: and a
perfect nativity finds its termination in itself. The Son has not a
Son, because the Father has not a Father. Thus the Father is the only
true Father, and the Son alone true Son; the Father only a Father, the
Son only a Son; being really in their Persons what human fathers are
but by office, character, accident, and name; vid. De Decr. 11,
note 6. And since the Father is unchangeable as Father, in nothing does
the Son more fulfil the idea of a perfect Image than in being
unchangeable too. Thus S. Cyril also, Thesaur. 10. p. 124. And
this perhaps may illustrate a strong and almost startling implication
of some of the Greek Fathers, that the First Person in the Holy
Trinity, is not God [in virtue of His Fatherhood]. E.g.
εἰ δὲ
θεὸς ὁ υἱ& 232·ς,
οὐκ ἐπεὶ υἱ&
231·ς· ὁμοίως
καὶ ὁ πατὴρ,
οὐκ ἐπεὶ
πατὴρ, θεός·
ἀλλ᾽ ἐπεὶ
οὐσία τοιάδε,
εἷς ἐστὶ
πατὴρ καὶ ὁ
υἱ& 232·ς
θεός. Nyssen. t. i.
p. 915. vid. Petav. de Deo i. 9. §13. Should it be asked,
‘What is the Father if not God?’ it is enough to answer,
‘the Father.’ Men differ from each other as being
individuals, but the characteristic difference between Father and Son
is, not that they are individuals, but that they are Father and
Son. In these extreme statements it must be ever borne in mind that we
are contemplating divine things according to our notions. not in
fact: i.e. speaking of the Almighty Father, as such;
there being no real separation between His Person and His Substance. It
may be added, that, though theologians differ in their decisions, it
would appear that our Lord is not the Image of the Father’s
person, but of the Father’s substance; in other words, not of the
Father considered as Father, but considered as God. That is, God the
Son is like and equal to God the Father, because they are both the same
God. De Syn. 49. note 4, also next note.