There can be little doubt however, that Ignatius wrote
γεννητός
καὶ
ἀγέννητος, though
his editors frequently alter it into γενητὸς καὶ
ἀγένητος. For
(1) the Greek ms. still retains the double
[Greek nun] ν, though the
claims of orthodoxy would be a temptation to scribes to substitute the single ν. And to this reading also the Latin
genitus et ingenitus points. On the other hand it cannot
be concluded that translators who give factus et non factus had
the words with one ν, for
this was after all what Ignatius meant by the double ν, and they would naturally render his words
so as to make his orthodoxy apparent. (2) When Theodoret writes
γεννητὸς ἐξ
ἀγεννήτου, it is
clear that he, or the person before him who first substituted this
reading, must have read γεννητὸς
καὶ
ἀγέννητος, for
there would be no temptation to alter the perfectly orthodox
γενητὸς καὶ
ἀγένητος, nor (if
altered) would it have taken this form. (3) When the interpolator
substitutes ὁ
μόνος
ἄληθινὸς
Θεὸς ὁ
ἀγέννητος…τοῦ δὲ
μονογονοῦς
πατῂρ καὶ
γεννήτωρ, the
natural inference is that he too, had the forms in double
ν, which he retained,
at the same time altering the whole run of the sentence so as not
to do violence to his own doctrinal views; see Bull Def. Fid.
Nic. ii. 2 § 6. (4) The quotation in Athanasius is
more difficult. The mss. vary, and
his editors write γενητὸς
καὶ
ἀγένητος.
Zahn too, who has paid more attention to this point than any
previous editor of Ignatius, in his former work (Ign. v.
Ant. p. 564), supposed Athanasius to have read and written
the words with a single ν, though in his subsequent edition of
Ignatius (p. 338) he declares himself unable to determine between
the single and double ν. I believe, however, that the
argument of Athanasius decides in favour of the νν. Elsewhere he insists
repeatedly on the distinction between κτίζειν and
γεννᾶν, justifying
the use of the latter term as applied to the divinity of the Son,
and defending the statement in the Nicene Creed γεννητὸν
ἐκ τῆς
οὐσίας τοῦ
πατρὸς τὸν
υἱὸν
ὁμοούσιον
(De Synod. 54, 1, p. 612). Although he is not
responsible for the language of the Macrostich (De Synod.
3, 1, p. 590), and would have regarded it as inadequate without
the ὁμοούσιον,
yet this use of terms entirely harmonizes with his own. In
the passage before us, ib. §§ 46, 47 (p. 607),
he is defending the use of homousios at Nicæa,
notwithstanding that it had been previously rejected by the
council which condemned Paul of Samosata, and he contends that
both councils were orthodox, since they used homousios in
a different sense. As a parallel instance he takes the word
ἀγέννητος
which like homousios is not a scriptural word, and like it
also is used in two ways, signifying either (1) Τὸ ὂν μεν,
μήτε δὲ
γεννηθὲν
μήτε ὅλως
ἔχον τὸν
αἴτιον, or (2) Τὸ
ἄκτιστον.
In the former sense the Son cannot be called ἀγέννητος,
in the latter he may be so called. Both uses, he says, are
found in the fathers. Of the latter he quotes the passage
in Ignatius as an example; of the former he says, that some
writers subsequent to Ignatius declare ἕν τὸ
ἀγέννητον ὁ
πατὴρ, καὶ
εἶς ὁ ἐξ
αὐτου υἱὸς
γνήσιος,
γέννημα
αληθίνον
κ.τ.λ. [He may have been thinking of
Clem. Alex. Strom. vi. 7, which I shall quote
below.] He maintains that both are orthodox, as having in
view two different senses of the word ἀγέννητον
, and the same, he argues, is the case with the councils which
seem to take opposite sides with regard to
homousios. It is clear from this passage, as Zahn
truly says, that Athanasius is dealing with one and the same word
throughout; and, if so, it follows that this word must be
ἀγέννητον,
since ἀγένητον
would be intolerable in some places. I may add by way of
caution that in two other passages, de Decret. Syn. Nic.
28 (1, p. 184), Orat. c. Arian. i. 30 (1, p. 343), St.
Athanasius gives the various senses of ἀγένητον
(for this is plain from the context), and that these passages
ought not to be treated as parallels to the present passage which
is concerned with the senses of ἀγέννητον
. Much confusion is thus created, e.g. in
Newman’s notes on the several passages in the Oxford
translation of Athanasius (pp. 51 sq., 224 sq.), where the three
passages are treated as parallel, and no attempt is made to
discriminate the readings in the several places, but
“ingenerate” is given as the rendering of both
alike. If then Athanasius who read γεννητὸς
καὶ
ἀγέννητος
in Ignatius, there is absolutely no authority for the spelling
with one ν. The
earlier editors (Voss, Ussher, Cotelier, etc.), printed it as
they found it in the ms.; but Smith
substituted the forms with the single ν, and he has been followed more recently by
Hefele, Dressel, and some other. In the Casanatensian copy
of the ms., a marginal note is added,
ἀναγνωστέον
ἀγένητος
τοῦτ᾽ ἔστι
μὴ
ποιηθείς.
Waterland (Works, III., p. 240 sq., Oxf. 1823) tries
ineffectually to show that the form with the double ν was invented by the fathers at a
later date to express their theological conception. He even
“doubts whether there was any such word as ἀγέννητος
so early as the time of Ignatius.” In this he is
certainly wrong.