In the writings of the supposed date
(356–362) of the Vita, references to monks are very
frequent (e.g. Apol. Fug. 4, Apol. Const. 29): but
previous to this (339) we find them mentioned in Encyl. §3,
and yet earlier, Apol. Ar. 67 (see below). In the letter to
Dracontius (Letter 49 in this vol.), corporate monasticism is
implied to be no novel institution. Dracontius himself (about 354) is
president of a monastery, and many other similar communities are
referred to. (Gwatkin deals with this letter in an unsatisfactory
fashion, p. 102, see the letter itself, §§7, 9, and notes.)
The letter to Amun, probably earlier than that just mentioned, is
clearly (sub. fin.) addressed to the head of a monastic society. Again,
the bishops Muis and Paulus of Letter 49, §7, who were
monks before their consecration, had been in the monastery of
Tabennæ before the death of Pachomius, which occurred almost
certainly in 346 (Eichhorn 12, 13. The whole history of Pachomius, who
was only a year or two older than Athanasius, although personally but
little known to him, his monastery being at Tabennæ, an island
near Philæ, is in conflict with Weingarten’s theory).
Lastly The
silence of Ep. Fest. X. (338) is made much of by Weingarten, but
there is nothing there to lead up to a reference to desert
monasticism. one of the most characteristic and life-like
of the documents relating to the case of Arsenius and the Council of
Tyre, namely the letter of Pinnes to John Arcaph (Apol. Ar. 67)
carries back the evidence earlier still. Pinnes is ‘presbyter of
a monastery’ (μονή):
that μονή here means a
society of monks, and not a posting station (Weing. in R. E., X.
p. 775) is clear from the mention of ‘Helias the monk,’ and
‘I, Paphnutius, monk of the same monastery.’ This
letter proves that there were not only Catholic but Meletian monks, and
these not hermits but in societies: and thus the origin of the solitary
type of monasticism goes back as far as the Meletian schism. (The
existence of Meletian monks is attested independently of this letter,
see Eich. p. 347.) Weingarten is quite unable to deal with this
obstacle to his theory. His argument is simply this: either the letter
has nothing to do with monks and monasteries (he overlooks Paphnutius),
or it must be rejected as spurious!
What reductio ad absurdum could be more complete? In an equally
desperate way he deals with the clear evidence of Aphraates,
Hom. vi., as to the existence of (at any rate) solitary
monasticism in Eastern Syria as early as 336. See Texte und
Untersuchungen iii. 3, pp. xvi. 89, &c. (Leipzig, 1888.)