194 ON THE TPJNITY. [BOOK YIL
to be God as to be, it is not right to say three essences, as it is
not right to say three Gods. But if it is one thing to God to
be, another to subsist, as it is one thing to God to be, another
to be the Father or the Lord ; for that which He is, is spoken
in respect to Himself, but He is called Father in relation to
the Son, and Lord in relation to the creature which serves
Him ; therefore He subsists relatively, as He begets relatively,
and bears rule relatively : so then substance will be no longer
substance, because it will be relative. For as from being He
is called essence, so from subsisting we speak of substance.
But it is absurd that substance should be spoken relatively,
for everything subsists in respect to itself ; how much more
God?
Chap. v.—In God, substance is spoken improperly, essenceproperly.
:j^ y^^s
'
10. If, however, it is fitting that God should be said to sub-
sist—(For that word is rightly understood of those things, in
which as subjects those things are, which are said to be in a
subject, as colour or shape in body. For body subsists, and
so is substance ; but those things are in the body, which sub-
sists and is their subject, and they are not substances, but are
in a substance : and so, if either that colour or that shape
ceases to be, it does not deprive the body of being a body,
because it is not of the being of body, that it should retain
this or that shape or colour ; therefore neither changeable nor
simple things are properly called substances.)—But if God
subsists so that He can be properly called a substance, then
there is something in Him as it were in a subject, and He is
not simple, i.e. such that to Him to be is the same as is any-
thing else that is said concerning Him in respect to Himself
;
as, for instance, great, omnipotent, good, and whatever of this
kind is not unfitly said of God. But it is an impiety to say
that God subsists, and is a subject to His own goodness, and
that this goodness is not a substance or rather essence, and that
God Himself is not His own goodness, but that it is in Him
as in a subject. And hence it is clear that God is improperly
called substance, in order that He may be understood to be by
the more usual name essence, which He is truly and properly
called; so that perhaps it is right that God alone should be called
essence. ForHe is truly alone, becauseHe is unchangeable ; and