Chapter
XCVII.
How impious, indeed, is the assertion of this man,
who charges us with impiety, that “not only are the irrational
animals wiser than the human race, but that they are more beloved by
God (than they)!” And who would not be repelled (by horror)
from paying any attention to a man who declared that a serpent, and a
fox, and a wolf, and an eagle, and a hawk, were more beloved by God
than the human race? For it follows from his maintaining such a
position, that if these animals be more beloved by God than human
beings, it is manifest that they are dearer to God than Socrates, and
Plato, and Pythagoras, and Pherecydes, and those theologians whose
praises he had sung a little before. And one might address him
with the prayer: “If these animals be dearer to God than
men, may you be beloved of God along with them, and be made like to
those whom you consider as dearer to Him than human
beings!” And let no one suppose that such a prayer is meant
as an imprecation; for who would not pray to resemble in all respects
those whom he believes to be dearer to God than others, in order that
he, like them, may enjoy the divine love? And as Celsus is
desirous to show that the assemblies of the irrational animals are more
sacred than ours, he ascribes the statement to that effect not to any
ordinary individuals, but to persons of intelligence. Yet it is
the virtuous alone who are truly wise, for no wicked man is so.
He speaks, accordingly, in the following style:
“Intelligent men say that these animals hold assemblies which are
more sacred than ours, and that they know what is spoken at them, and
actually prove that they are not without such knowledge, when they
mention beforehand that the birds have announced their intention of
departing to a particular place, or of doing this thing or that, and
then show that they
have
departed to the place in question, and
have done the particular thing which was foretold.” Now,
truly, no person of intelligence ever related such things; nor did any
wise man ever say that the assemblies of the irrational animals were
more sacred than those of men. But if, for the purpose of
examining (the soundness of) his statements, we look to their
consequences, it is evident that, in his opinion, the assemblies of the
irrational animals are more sacred than those of the venerable
Pherecydes, and Pythagoras, and Socrates, and Plato, and of
philosophers in general; which assertion is not only
incongruous
4064
in itself, but full
of absurdity. In order that we may believe, however, that certain
individuals
do
learn from the indistinct sound of birds that
they are about to take their departure, and do this thing or that, and
announce these things beforehand, we would say that this information is
imparted to men by demons by means of signs, with the view of having
men deceived by demons, and having their understanding dragged down
from God and heaven to earth, and to places lower
still.
4064
ἀπεμφαῖνον
.