cause. On this truth are founded all reasonings and all metaphysical evidence. 2. Sin is an effect, and has a cause.
On this truth are founded all moral means and all religious principles. 3. The origin of moral evil cannot be
moral evil; or, the cause of sin cannot be sin itself. Except we admit this, the same thing may be and not be, at
the same time, and in the same respect—the same thing may be sin and no sin—cause and no cause—or, contrary
to the first axiom, a contingent event may be the cause of itself, or may exist without an adequate cause. 4. There
is no positive cause but what is ultimately from God. If otherwise, something positive may begin to be without
a positive cause; or, something may exist without an adequate cause; which is the same as an effect to exist
without a cause, contrary to the first axiom. 5. There may be a negative, metaphysical cause, where there is no
decretive divine operation to effect it were there no negative metaphysical causes, such ideas as absence, ignorance,
folly, weakness, and the like, could have no metaphysical effects; contrary to universal experience. And we must
renounce all ideas of congruity to suppose that such things are the mere effects of divine decree and operation.
Having premised these positions as axioms not to be disputed, we proceed to make a few observations, which,
though equally true, may not be equally obvious. 6. The origin of moral evil cannot be one principle. For were
it one, it must be either a positive or negative cause. If positive, it would be ultimately from God; but this would
exclude a moral alternative, the very essence of moral agency, and consequently be incompatible with the existence
of moral evil. But if a negative cause, it must ultimately be referred to the prime negative cause, which can be
no other than passive power, as before explained; which is nothing independent of positive existence; and con-
sequently can have no effect but in union with positive existence. 7. It remains, then, that the origin of moral
evil is a compound of two causes at least. Yet not more than two; because, as we shall see, these are sufficient,
and more would be superfluous, in order to produce the effect. 8. Now the question remains, What are these
compound principles? Are they two positive causes, two negative causes, or one of each? They cannot be two
positive causes; for then they might be ultimately reduced to one, the first cause; as before proved, gr. 4, 6. Nor
can they be two negative ones; for ultimately there is but one cause properly negative. Consequently, 9. The first
entrance of sin into the world, or the true and precise origin of moral evil, may be found in two causes united;
the one positive and the other negative. But neither of which is morally good or morally evil; if the cause were
morally good, the effect could not be morally bad; and if morally evil, it would be contrary to the third axiom,
and to common sense. These two causes are, first, liberty, a cause naturally good; secondly, passive power, a
cause naturally evil. And these two causes are as necessary for the production of moral evil, as two parents for
the production of a human being according to the taws of nature, 9. Dr. Clarke, whose brief account has been
more implicitly admitted than any other, says, that moral evil “arises wholly from the abuse of liberty; which
God gave to his creatures for other purposes, and which it was reasonable and fit to give them for the perfection
and order of the whole creation: only they, contrary to God’s intention and command, have abused what was
necessary for the perfection of the whole, to the corruption and depravation of themselves.” This extract from
Dr. Clarke (in his Demonstration of the Being and Attributes of God. p. 113. 5th edit) has been advanced by
celebrated writers, as “containing all that can be advanced with certainty ” on the subject. But surety those minds
must be easily satisfied, who can be satisfied with such evidence. Dr. Clarke allows and proves, that liberty is a
perfection, rather than an evil. How came it then to product evil? He answers, “This arises wholly from the abuse
of liberty. But what is the cause of this effect called “the abuse of liberty?” This in fact is the whole of the difficulty,
and yet he leaves it untouched. The free agent fails in the exercise of liberty; this failure is an effect; but there is
745
SECTION X. Concerning sin's first Entrance into the world.