division, but God the Word cannot be generated from the Father without the essence of the
Father being divided! Is any one so witless as not to perceive the irrational character of his
position? “Not dividing,” quoth he, “His own essence by begetting.” Why, whose own essence
is divided by begetting? For in the case of men essence means human nature: in the case of
brutes, it means, generically, brute nature, but in the case of cattle, sheep, and all brute an-
imals, specifically, it is regarded according to the distinctions of their kinds. Which, then,
of these divides its own essence by the process of generation? Does not the nature always
remain undiminished in the case of every animal by the succession of its posterity? Further
a man in begetting a man from himself does not divide his nature, but it remains in its fulness
alike in him who begets and in him who is begotten, not split off and transferred from the
one to the other, nor mutilated in the one when it is fully formed in the other, but at once
existing in its entirety in the former and discoverable in its entirety in the latter. For both
before begetting his child the man was a rational animal, mortal, capable of intelligence and
knowledge, and also after begetting a man endowed with such qualities: so that in him are
shown all the special properties of his nature; as he does not lose his existence as a man by
begetting the man derived from him, but remains after that event what he was before without
causing any diminution of the nature derived from him by the fact that the man derived
from him comes into being.
Well, man is begotten of man, and the nature of the begetter is not divided. Yet Euno-
mius does not admit that the Only-begotten God, Who is in the bosom of the Father, is
110
truly of the Father, for fear forsooth, lest he should mutilate the inviolable nature of the
Father by the subsistence of the Only-begotten: but after saying “Not dividing His essence
by begetting,” he adds, “Or being Himself begetter and begotten, or Himself becoming
Father and Son312,” and thinks by such loose disjointed phrases to undermine the true
confession of godliness or to furnish some support to his own ungodliness, not being aware
that by the very means he uses to construct a reductio ad absurdum he is discovered to be
an advocate of the truth. For we too say that He who has all that belongs to His own Father
is all that He is, save being Father, and that He who has all that belongs to the Son exhibits
in Himself the Son in His completeness, save being Son: so that the reductio ad absurdum,
which Eunomius here invents, turns out to be a support of the truth, when the notion is
expanded by us so as to display it more clearly, under the guidance of the Gospel. For if “he
that hath seen the Son seeth the Father313” then the Father begat another self, not passing
out of Himself, and at the same time appearing in His fulness in Him: so that from these
considerations that which seemed to have been uttered against godliness is demonstrated
to be a support of sound doctrine.
312 The quotation does not verbally correspond with Eunomius’ words as cited above.
313 Cf. S. John xiv. 9
210
Gregory further shows that the Only-Begotten being begotten not only of…