added by Paul’s working miracles like those done by the apostles, his authority became so
great, that his words are now received in the Church, as if, to use his own appropriate words,
Christ were speaking in him.1010 Manichæus, on the other hand, thinks that the Church
of Christ should believe what he says in opposition to the Scriptures, which are supported
by such strong and continuous evidence, and in which the Church finds an emphatic injunc-
tion, that whoever preaches to her differently from what she has received must be ana-
thema.1011
5. Faustus tells us that he has good grounds for concluding that these Scriptures are
unworthy of credit. And yet he speaks of not using arguments. But the argument too shall
be refuted. The end of the whole argument is to bring the soul to believe that the reason of
its misery in this world is, that it is the means of preventing God from being deprived of
His kingdom, and that God’s substance and nature is so exposed to change, corruption, in-
jury, and contamination, that part of it is incurably defiled, and is consigned by Himself to
eternal punishment in the mass of darkness, though, when it was in harmless union with
Himself, and guilty of no crime, He knowingly sent it where it was to suffer defilement.
This is the end of all your arguments and fictions; and would that there were an end of them
as regards your heart and your lips, that you might sometime desist from believing and ut-
tering those execrable blasphemies! But, says Faustus, I prove from the writings themselves
that they cannot be in all points trustworthy, for they contradict one another. Why not say,
then, that they are wholly untrustworthy, if their testimony is inconsistent and self-contra-
dictory? But, says Faustus, I say what I think to be in accordance with truth. With what
truth? The truth is only your own fiction, which begins with God’s battle, goes on to His
contamination, and ends with His damnation. No one, says Faustus, believes writings which
contradict themselves. But if you think they do this, it is because you do not understand
them; for your ignorance has been manifested in regard to the passages you have quoted in
support of your opinion, and the same will appear in regard to any quotations you may still
make. So there is no reason for our not believing these writings, supported as they are by
such weighty testimony; and this is itself the best reason for pronouncing accursed those
whose preaching differs from what is there written.
————————————
1010 2 Cor. xiii. 3.
1011 Gal. i. 8, 9.
556
Faustus recurs to the genealogy and insists upon examining it as regards…