Thus it appears, if we consider matters strictly, there is no such thing as any identity or
oneness in created objects, existing at different times, but what depends on God’s sovereign
constitution. And so it appears, that the objection we are upon, made against a supposed
divine constitution, whereby Adam and his posterity are viewed and treated as one, in the
manner and for the purposes supposed—as if it were not consistent with truth, because no
constitution can make those to be one, which are not one—is built on a false hypothesis: for
it appears, that a divine constitution is what makes truth, in affairs of this nature. The objection
supposes, there is a oneness in created beings, whence qualities and relations are derived
down from past existence, distinct from, and prior to, any oneness that can be supposed to
be founded on divine constitution. Which is demonstrably false; and sufficiently appears so
from things conceded by the adversaries themselves: and therefore the objection wholly
falls to the ground.
There are various kinds of identity and oneness, found among created things, by which
225
they become one in different manners, respects, and degrees, and to various purposes; several
of which differences have been observed; and every kind is ordered, regulated, and limited,
in every respect, by divine constitution. Some things, existing in different times and places,
are treated by their Creator as one in one respect, and others in another; some are united for
this communication, and others for that; but all according to the sovereign pleasure of the
fountain of all being and operation.
It appears, particularly, from what has been said, that all oneness, by virtue whereof
pollution and guilt from past wickedness are derived, depends entirely on a divine establish-
ment. It is this, and this only, that must account for guilt and an evil taint on any individual
soul, in consequence of a crime committed twenty or forty years ago, remaining still, and
even to the end of the world, and for ever. It is this that must account for the continuance
of any such thing, and where, as consciousness of acts that are past; and for the continuance
of all habits, either good or bad: and on this depends every thing that can belong to personal
identity. And all communications, derivations, or continuation of qualities, properties, or
relations, natural or moral, from what is past, as if the subject were one, depends on no
other foundation.
And I am persuaded, that no solid reason can be given, why God—who constitutes all
other created union or oneness according to his pleasure, and for what purposes, commu-
nications, and effects he pleases—may not establish a constitution whereby the natural
posterity of Adam, proceeding from him, much as the buds and branches from the stock or
root of a tree, should be treated as one with him, for the derivation, either of righteousness,
and communion in rewards, or of the loss of righteousness, and consequent corruption and
guilt. 154
154 I appeal to such as are not wont to content themselves with judging by a superficial appearance and view
of things, but are habituated to examine things strictly and closely, that they may judge righteous judgment,
1161
CHAPTER III. The Imputation of Adam's Sin stated.