Chapter 10.—Concerning the Liberty of Seneca, Who More Vehemently Censured the
Civil Theology Than Varro Did the Fabulous.
That liberty, in truth, which this man wanted, so that he did not dare to censure that
theology of the city, which is very similar to the theatrical, so openly as he did the theatrical
itself, was, though not fully, yet in part possessed by Annæus Seneca, whom we have some
evidence to show to have flourished in the times of our apostles. It was in part possessed
by him, I say, for he possessed it in writing, but not in living. For in that book which he
wrote against superstition,248 he more copiously and vehemently censured that civil and
urban theology than Varro the theatrical and fabulous. For, when speaking concerning
images, he says, “They dedicate images of the sacred and inviolable immortals in most
worthless and motionless matter. They give them the appearance of man, beasts, and fishes,
and some make them of mixed sex, and heterogeneous bodies. They call them deities, when
they are such that if they should get breath and should suddenly meet them, they would be
held to be monsters.” Then, a while afterwards, when extolling the natural theology, he had
expounded the sentiments of certain philosophers, he opposes to himself a question, and
says, “Here some one says, Shall I believe that the heavens and the earth are gods, and that
some are above the moon and some below it? Shall I bring forward either Plato or the
peripatetic Strato, one of whom made God to be without a body, the other without a mind?”
In answer to which he says, “And, really, what truer do the dreams of Titus Tatius, or Ro-
mulus, or Tullus Hostilius appear to thee? Tatius declared the divinity of the goddess
Cloacina; Romulus that of Picus and Tiberinus; Tullus Hostilius that of Pavor and Pallor,
the most disagreeable affections of men, the one of which is the agitation of the mind under
fright, the other that of the body, not a disease, indeed, but a change of color.” Wilt thou
rather believe that these are deities, and receive them into heaven? But with what freedom
he has written concerning the rites themselves, cruel and shameful! “One,” he says, “castrates
himself, another cuts his arms. Where will they find room for the fear of these gods when
angry, who use such means of gaining their favor when propitious? But gods who wish to
be worshipped in this fashion should be worshipped in none. So great is the frenzy of the
mind when perturbed and driven from its seat, that the gods are propitiated by men in a
manner in which not even men of the greatest ferocity and fable-renowned cruelty vent
their rage. Tyrants have lacerated the limbs of some; they never ordered any one to lacerate
his own. For the gratification of royal lust, some have been castrated; but no one ever, by
the command of his lord, laid violent hands on himself to emasculate himself. They kill
themselves in the temples. They supplicate with their wounds and with their blood. If any
one has time to see the things they do and the things they suffer, he will find so many things
unseemly for men of respectability, so unworthy of freemen, so unlike the doings of sane
248 Mentioned also by Tertullian, Apol. 12, but not extant.
Concerning the Liberty of Seneca, Who More Vehemently Censured the Civil Theology Than Varro Did the Fabulous.
280
Concerning the Liberty of Seneca, Who More Vehemently Censured the Civil…