lationem. Why make such a charge? Why does Primian say, it is unworthy for the sons of
the martyrs to meet in the same place with the offspring of traditors? Why did they come?
Why were they unable to prove the old accusations? And how are they the sons of martyrs?
The universality of the Church was demonstrated at the Conference. Donatists do not
commune with the churches addressed in those epistles which they read at their services,
because they say these perished by communion with the African Cæcilians, and yet they
put in the plea that a case should not be prejudged by a case nor a person by a person. He
meets the Cæcilian charge by the Maximianists in spite of this caveat. He represents all the
New Testament churches and the East as expostulating on the basis of this very plea with
the Donatists for separation from them. So the case and the person of the bad does not
prejudice the case and the person of the good; they must abide together until the end. He
condemns their arrogant pretense to holiness. The wicked must be tolerated in the Church,
but their deeds are not to be participated in. Cyprian would not destroy the unity because
bad people were in it; frequent are the examples of such forbearance in the Scriptures, and
the principle was not changed after the resurrection of Christ; it continued in force in the
New Testament Church; the winnowing and severance come at the end of the world. They
would perhaps deny their own words as uttered in the Conference were they not written;
that was the beauty of requiring subscription. They charge too that the sentence against
them was pronounced in the night. Augustin playfully speaks of many good things which
have been said and done in the night. He subsequently reminds them of the days in which
they tried to prove the origin of heresy, and their defeat at every point of the Cæcilian history.
It appears here again that the Donatists had a considerable body of acts of their own. The
398
plea of persecution as a note of the Church and as an experience of the Donatists was one
of the points urged at the conference in the Donatist reply to the Catholic mandate, and by
Primian, to which we have the usual answer. Another complaint of the Donatists was that
they were tried by those who had been condemned by themselves, and were compelled to
unite with sinners; to which Augustin gives a little Maximianist parallel and then considers
the questions of purism, the paucity of believers, the need of discipline, the fellowship of a
mixed community which ought not to degenerate into a participation in the deeds of the
wicked therein. These are discussed with considerable detail of quotations from the Old
and New Testaments. Some who thought Cæcilian guilty would not break the unity; they
imitated Cyprian. He charges their clergy with duplicity. He reminds them of the deception
practiced in presenting the signature of a Donatist, who was already dead; so with regard
to the show of numbers in attendance and the alleged multitude absent, and also the means
adopted for securing delay, the interruptions and turnings of the debate from the true object
in view. He vindicates the cognitor’s method and rulings. He then renews the discussion
concerning the archival origin of the schism. In conclusion he addresses them as brethren
and exhorts them to love peace and unity.
680
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.