hensive and perfect enough, our view of the present state of the world would excite in us a
perfect idea of all past changes.
And we need not perplex our minds with a thousand questions and doubts that will
seem to arise: as, To what purpose is this way of exciting ideas? and, What advantage is there
in observing such a series? I answer, It is just all one, as to any benefit or advantage, any end
that we can suppose was proposed by the Creator, as if the Material Universe were existent
in the same manner as is vulgarly thought. For the corporeal would is to no advantage but
to the spiritual; and it is exactly the same advantage this way as the other, for it is all one, as
to any thing excited in the mind.
[51.] It is hardly proper to say, that the dependence of ideas of sensation upon the organs
of the body, is only the dependence of some of our ideas upon others. For the organs of our
bodies are not our ideas, in a proper sense, though their existence be only mental. Yet there
is no necessity of their existing actually in our minds, but they exist mentally, in the same
manner as has been explained. See above, No. 34. The dependence of our ideas upon the
organs, is the dependence of our ideas on our bodies, after the manner there explained,
mentally existing. And if it be inquired, To what purpose is this way of exciting ideas? I an-
swer, To exactly the same purpose as can be supposed, if our organs are actually existing,
in the manner vulgarly conceived, as to any manner of benefit, or end, that can be mentioned.
It is not proper at all, nor doth it express the thing we would, to say that bodies do not
exist without the mind. For the scheme will not allow the mind to be supposed determined
to any place, in such a manner as to make that proper; for Place itself is mental, and Within
and Without are mere mental conceptions. Therefore, that way of expressing, will lead us
ccxviii
into a thousand difficulties and perplexities. But when I say the Material Universe exists
only in the mind, I mean, that it is absolutely dependent on the conception of the mind for
its existence, and does not exist as Spirits do, whose existence does not consist in, nor in
dependence on, the conception of other minds. We must be exceedingly careful, lest we
confound ourselves in these by mere imagination. It is from hence I expect the greatest op-
position. It will appear a ridiculous thing, I suppose, that the material world exists no where,
but in the soul of man, confined within his skull; but we must again remember what sort of
existence the head and brain have.—The soul, in a sense, has its seat in the brain; and so, in
a sense, the visible world is existent out of the mind, for it certainly, in the most proper
sense, exists out of the brain.
[36.] Things, as to God, exist from all Eternity, alike; that is, the idea is always the same,
and after the same mode. The existence of things, therefore, that are not actually in created
minds, consists only in Power, or in the Determination of God, that such and such ideas
shall be raised in created minds, upon such conditions.
[40.] Since all material existence is only idea, this question may be asked, In what sense
may those things be said to exist, which are supposed, and yet are in no actual idea of any
469
NO.IV. Remarks in Mental Philosophy. The Mind.