the lips does not abide in the air. And from this we may see the unsubstantial character of
his assertions; because, even if without speech we describe in writing our mental conceptions,
it is not as though the substantial objects of our thoughts will acquire their significance from
the letters, while the non-substantial will have no part in what the letters express. For
whatever comes into our mind, whether intellectually existing, or otherwise, it is possible
for us at our discretion to store away in writing. And the voice and letters are of equal value
for the expression of thought, for we communicate what we think by the latter as well as by
the former. What he sees, then, to justify his making the mental conception perish with the
255
voice only, I fail to comprehend. For in the case of all speech uttered by means of sound,
the passage of the breath indeed which conveys the voice is towards its kindred element,
but the sense of the words spoken is engraved by hearing on the memory of the hearer’s
soul, whether it be true or false. Is not this, then, a weak interpretation of this “conception”
of his that our writer offers, when he characterizes and defines it by the dissolution of the
voice? And for this reason the understanding hearer, as saith Isaiah, objects to this incon-
ceivable account of mental conception, showing it, to use the man’s own words, to be a
veritably dissoluble and unsubstantial one, and he discusses scientifically the force inherent
in the term, advancing his argument by familiar examples to the contemplation of doctrine.
Against whom Eunomius exalting himself with this pompous writing, endeavours to over-
throw the true account of mental conception, after this manner.
But before we examine what he has written, it may be better to enquire with what purpose
it is that he refuses to admit that ungenerate can be predicated of God by way of conception.
Now the tenet which has been held in common by all who have received the word of our
religion is, that all hope of salvation should be placed in Christ, it being impossible for any
to be found among the righteous, unless faith in Christ supply what is desired. And this
conviction being firmly established in the souls of the faithful, and all honour and glory and
worship being due to the Only-begotten God as the Author of life, Who doeth the works of
the Father, as the Lord Himself saith in the Gospel1074, and Who falls short of no excellence
in all knowledge of that which is good, I know not how they have been so perverted by ma-
lignity and jealousy of the Lord’s honour, that, as though they judged the worship paid by
the faithful to the Only-begotten God to be a detriment to themselves, they oppose His Divine
honours, and try to persuade us that nothing that is said of them is true. For with them
neither is He very God, though called so, it would seem, by Scripture, nor, though called
Son, has He a nature that makes good the appellation, nor has He a community of dignity
or of nature with the Father. For, say they, it is not possible for Him that is begotten to be
of equal honour with Him Who made Him, either in dignity, or in power, or in nature, be-
cause the life of the latter is infinite, and His existence from eternity, while the life of the
1074 S. John x. 37
485
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.