How much protection the Lord has extended to His Church through your clemency, we
have often tested by many signs. And whatever stand the
strenuousness of the priesthood has made in our times against the
assailers of the catholic Truth, has redounded chiefly to your
glory: seeing that, as you have learnt from the teaching of the
Holy Spirit, you submit your authority in all things to Him, by whose
favour and under whose protection you reign. Wherefore, because I
have ascertained from my brother and fellow-bishop Flavian’s
report, that a certain dispute has been raised through the agency of
Eutyches in the church of Constantinople against the integrity of the
Christian faith (and the text of the synod’s minutes has shown me
the exact nature of the whole matter), it is worthy of your great name
that the error which in my opinion proceeds rather from ignorance than
ingenuity, should be dispelled before, with the pertinacity of
wrong-headedness, it gains any strength from the support of the
unwise. Because even ignorance sometimes falls into serious
mistakes, and very frequently the simple-minded rush through unwariness
into the devil’s pit: and it is thus, I believe, that the
spirit of falsehood has crept over Eutyches: so that, whilst he
imagines himself to appreciate the majesty of the Son of God more devoutly, by denying in Him the real presence of
our nature, he came to the conclusion that the whole of that Word which
“became flesh” was of one and the same essence. And
greatly as Nestorius fell away from the Truth, in asserting that Christ
was only born man of His mother, this man also departs no less far from
the catholic path, who does not believe that our substance was brought
forth from the same Virgin: wishing it of course to be understood
as belonging to His Godhead only; so that that which took the form of a
slave, and was like us and of the same form Quod nostri
similis fuit atque conformis.,
was a kind of image, not the reality of our nature.