6. Moreover he has dared to say, that ‘the
Word is not the very God;’ ‘though He is called God, yet He
is not very God,’ but ‘by participation of grace, He, as
others, is God only in name.’ And, whereas all beings are foreign
and different from God in essence, so too is ‘the Word alien and
unlike in all things to the Father’s essence and
propriety,’ but belongs to things originated and created, and is
one of these. Afterwards, as though he had succeeded to the
devil’s recklessness, he has stated in his Thalia, that
‘even to the Son the Father is invisible,’ and ‘the
Word cannot perfectly and exactly either see or know His own
Father;’ but even what He knows and what He sees, He knows and
sees ‘in proportion to His own measure,’ as we also know
according to our own power. For the Son, too, he says, not only knows
not the Father exactly, for He fails in comprehension Vid.
de Syn. 15, note 6. κατάληψις
was originally a Stoic word, and even when considered
perfect, was, properly speaking, attributable only to an imperfect
being. For it is used in contrast to the Platonic doctrine of
ἴδεαι, to express the
hold of things obtained by the mind through the senses; it being a
Stoical maxim, nihil esse in intellectu quod non fuerit in sensu. In
this sense it is also used by the Fathers, to mean real and certain
knowledge after inquiry, though it is also ascribed to Almighty God. As
to the position of Arius, since we are told in Scripture that none
‘knoweth the things of a man save the spirit of man which is in
him,’ if κατάληψις
be an exact and complete knowledge of the object of
contemplation, to deny that the Son comprehended the Father, was to
deny that He was in the Father, i.e. the doctrine of the περιχώρησις, de Syn. 15, ἀνεπιμικτοί, or to maintain that He was a distinct, and therefore a
created, being. On the other hand Scripture asserts that, as the Holy
Spirit which is in God, ‘searcheth all things, yea, the deep
things of God,’ so the Son, as being ‘in the bosom of the
Father,’ alone ‘hath declared Him.’ vid. Clement.
Strom. v. 12. And thus Athan. speaking of Mark xiii. 32, ’If the
Son is in the Father and the Father in the Son, and the Father knows
the day and the hour, it is plain that the Son too, being in the
Father, and knowing the things in the Father, Himself also knows the
day and the hour.” Orat. iii. 44., but ‘He knows not even His own
essence;’—and that ‘the essences of the Father and
the Son and the Holy Ghost, are separate in nature, and estranged, and
disconnected, and alien de
Decr. 25, note 2., and without
participation of each other de
Syn. 15.;’ and, in his
own words, ‘utterly unlike from each other in essence and glory,
unto infinity.’ Thus as to ‘likeness of glory and
essence,’ he says that the Word is entirely diverse from both the
Father and the Holy Ghost. With such words hath the irreligious spoken;
maintaining that the Son is distinct by Himself, and in no respect
partaker of the Father. These are portions of Arius’s fables as
they occur in that jocose composition.