Chapter XVI.—The
Unbegotten and the Begotten Necessarily Different from Each
Other.
“In addition to this, it is the peculiarity
of the Father not to have been begotten, but of the Son to have been
begotten; but what is begotten cannot be compared with that which is
unbegotten or self-begotten.” And Simon said:
“Is it not the same on account of its origin?”
1300
And Peter said: “He who is
not the same in all respects as some one, cannot have all the same
appellations applied to him as that person.” And Simon
said: “This is to assert, not to prove.” And
Peter said: “Why, do you not see that if
1301
the one happens to be self-begotten or
unbegotten, they cannot be called the same; nor can it be asserted of
him who has been begotten that he is of the same substance as he is who
has begotten him?
1302
Learn this
also: The bodies of men have immortal souls, which have been
clothed with the breath of God; and having come forth from God, they
are of the same substance, but they are not gods. But if they are
gods, then in this way the souls of all men, both those who have died,
and those who are alive, and those who shall come into being, are
gods. But if in a spirit of controversy you maintain that these
also are gods, what great matter is it, then, for Christ to be called
God? for He has only what all have.
1300
The word
γένεσις
,
“arising, coming into being,” is here used, not
γέννησις
,
“begetting.” The idea fully expressed is:
“Is not that which is begotten identical in essence with that
which begets it?”
1301
We have inserted
εἰ
. The passage
is amended in various ways; this seems to be the simplest.
1302
[The very ancient
variant in
John i.
18
, “God only
begotten,” indicates the distinction between the Unbegotten God
and the Son. Even the Arians use the phrase, “Only-begotten
God.”—R.]