unharmed, when the deserters are either punished with a severe sentence, or, in the exercise
369
of clemency, restored. If, in regard to this, any more particular inquiry is to be made, that
is, as I have said another question; for in these things, the practice of the Church of God is
the rule of our practice.
10. The question between us, however, is, whether your Church or ours is the Church
of God. To resolve this, we must begin with the original inquiry, why you became schismatics.
If you do not write me an answer, I believe that before the bar of God I shall be easily vin-
dicated as having done my duty in this matter; because I have sent a letter in the interests
of peace to a man of whom I have heard that, excepting only his adherence to schismatics,
he is a good and well-educated man. Be it yours to consider how you shall answer Him
whose forbearance now demands your praise, and His judgment shall in the end demand
your fears. If, however, you write a reply to me with as much care as you see me to have
bestowed upon this, I believe that, by the mercy of God, the error which now keeps us apart
shall perish before the love of peace and the logic of truth. Observe that I have said nothing
about the followers of Rogatus,2097 who call you Firmiani, as you call us Macariani. Nor
have I spoken of your bishop of Rucata (or Rusicada), who is said to have made an agreement
with Firmus, promising, on condition of the safety of all his adherents, that the gates should
be opened to him, and the Catholics given up to slaughter and pillage. Many other such
things I pass unnoticed. Do you therefore in like manner desist from the commonplaces of
rhetorical exaggeration concerning actions of men which you have either heard of or known;
for you see how I am silent concerning deeds of your party, in order to confine the debate
to the question upon which the whole matter hinges, namely, the origin of the schism.
My brother, beloved and longed for, may the Lord our God breathe into you thoughts
tending towards reconciliation.
2097 Rogatus, bishop of Cartenna in Mauritania, who left the Donatists and suffered much persecution at
the hands of Firmus, a brother of Gildo; hence the Donatists were named by the Rogatists Firmiani. See Augustin,
Contra Literas Petiliani, book ii. ch. 83.
821
To Emeritus