440 JEROME.-
were to order a ship to be restored after ship-
wreck, and then were to refuse each particu-
lar thing of which a ship is made.
31. I will speak freely, and although you
screw your mouths, pull your hair, stamp
your feet, and take up stones like the Jews,
I will openly confess the faith of the Church.
The reality of a resurrection without flesh and
bones, without blood and members, is unin-
telligible. Where there are flesh and bones,
where there are blood and members, there
must of necessity be diversity of sex. Where
there is diversity of sex, there John is John,
Mary is Mary. You need not fear the mar-
riage of those who, even before death, lived in
their own sex without discharging the func-
tions of sex. When it is said, " In that day
they shall neither marry, nor be given in mar-
riage," the words refer to those who can marry, and yet will not do so. For no one
says of the angels, " They shall not marry,
nor be given in marriage." I never heard of a marriage being celebrated among the spirit- ual virtues in heaven : but where there is sex,
there you have man and woman, Hence it is
that, although you were reluctant, you were
compelled by the truth to confess that, " A man must either be crowned in the body be-
cause he lived a pure and upright life, or
be condemned in the body, because he was
the slave of pleasure and iniquity." Sub- stitute flesh for body, and you have not denied the existence of male and female.
Who can have any glory from a life of
chastity if we have no sex which would make
unchastity possible ? Who ever crowned a
stone for continuing a virgin ? Likeness to
the angels is promised us, that is, the blessed-
ness of their angelic existence without flesh and sex will be bestowed on us in our flesh
and with our sex. I am simple enough so
to believe, and so know how to confess that
sex can exist without the functions of the
senses ; that it is thus that men rise, and that it
is thus that they are made equal to the an-
gels. Nor will the resurrection of the mem-
bers all at once seem superfluous, because
they are to have no office, since, while we are
still in this life, we strive not to perform the
works of the members. Moreover, likeness
to the angels does not imply a changing of
men into angels, but their growth in immor-
tality and glory.
32. But as for the arguments drawn from
boys, and infants, and old men, and meats, and
excrements, which you employ against the
Church, they are not your own ; they flow from a heathen source. For the heathen
mock us with the same. You say you are a
Christian ; lay aside the weapons of the
heathen. It is for them to learn from you
to confess the resurrection of the dead, not
for you to learn from them to deny it. Or if
you belong to the enemy's camp, show your- self openly as an adversary, that you may share the wounds we inflict on the heathen.
I will allow you your jest about the necessity
of nursemaids to stop the infants from
crying ; of the decrepit old men, who, you fear,
would be shrivelled with winter's cold. I will admit also that the barbers have learnt
their craft for nothing, for do we not know
that the people of Israel for forty years
experienced no growth of either nails or
hair ; and, still more, their clothes were not
worn out, nor did their shoes wax old ?
Enoch and Elias, concerning whom we spoke
a while ago, abide all this time in the same
state in which they were carried away. They
have teeth, belly, organs of generation, and
yet have no need of meats, or wives. Why
do you slander the power of God, who can
from that ^marrow and seed-plot of which you speak, not only produce flesh from flesh, but
also make one body from another ; and
change water, that is worthless flesh, into the
precious wine of an aerial body ? the same
power by which He created all things out
of nothing can give back what has existed,
because it is a much smaller thing to restore
what has been, than to make what never
was. Do you wonder that there is a resur- rection from the condition of infancy and old
age to that of mature manhood, seeing that
a perfect man was made out of the slime of
the earth without having gone through suc-
cessive stages of growth ? A rib is changed
into a woman ; and by the third mode of
creating man, the poor elements of our birth
which put us to the blush are changed into
flesh, bound together by the members, run
into veins, harden into bones. There is a
fourth sort of human generation of which I
can tell you. " The Holy Spirit shall come upon thee, and the power of the Highest shall
overshadow thee. Wherefore that * holy thing which shall be born of thee shall be called the
Son of God." Adam was created one way, Eve another, Abel another, the man Jesus
Christ another. And yet, different as are all
1 these beginnings, the nature of man remains one and the same.
33. If I wished to prove the resurrection of
the flesh and of all the members, and to give the
meaning of the several passages, many books
would be required ; but the matter in hand
does not call for this. For I purposed not to
reply to Origen in every detail, but to dis-
close the mysteries of your insincere " Apol-
1 Besides medulla, and seminarium Jerome has ivrepiiavri =
inward part, Of pith. 2 Luke i. 35.
i