16. For if it be not so, but the Word is a
creature and a work out of nothing, either He is not True God because
He is Himself one of the creatures, or if they name Him God from regard
for the Scriptures, they must of necessity say that there are two
Gods Vid.
p. 75, note 7; de Syn. 27 (2), and 50, note 5. The Arians were
in the dilemma of holding two gods or worshipping the creature, unless
they denied to our Lord both divinity and worship. vid. de Decr.
6, note 5, Or. i. 30, n. 1. But ‘every substance,’
says S. Austin, ‘which is not God, is a creature, and which is
not a creature, is God.’ de Trin. i. 6. And so S. Cyril
in Joan. p. 52. vid. also Naz. Orat. 31, 6. Basil.
contr. Eunom. ii. 31., one Creator, the other creature, and must
serve two Lords, one Unoriginate, and the other originate and a
creature; and must have two faiths, one in the True God, and the other
in one who is made and fashioned by themselves and called God. And it
follows of necessity in so great blindness, that, when they worship the
Unoriginate, they renounce the originate, and when they come to the
creature, they turn from the Creator. For they cannot see the One in
the Other, because their natures and operations are foreign and
distinct §11, n. 4.. And with such sentiments, they will
certainly be going on to more gods, for this will be the essay ἐπιχείρημα, de Decr. 1, note. of those who revolt from the One God.
Wherefore then, when the Arians have these speculations and views, do
they not rank themselves with the Gentiles? for they too, as these,
worship the creature rather than God the Creator of all Vid.
supr. ii. 14, n. 7. Petavius gives a large collection of
passages, de Trin. ii. 12. §5. from the Fathers in proof of
the worship of Our Lord evidencing His Godhead. On the Arians as
idolaters vid. supr. Or. i. 8, n. 8. also Ep. Æg. 4,
13. and Adelph. 3 init. Serap. i. 29, d. Theodoret in
Rom. i. 25., and though they shrink from the Gentile
name, in order to deceive the unskilful, yet they secretly hold a like
sentiment with them. For their subtle saying which they are accustomed
to urge, We say not two ‘Unoriginates Or. i. 30, n. 1.,’ they plainly say to deceive the
simple; for in their very professing ‘We say not two
Unoriginates,’ they imply two Gods, and these with different
natures, one originate and one Unoriginate. And though the Greeks
worship one Unoriginate and many originate, but these one Unoriginate
and one originate, this is no difference from them; for the God whom they call
originate is one out of many, and again the many gods of the Greeks
have the same nature with this one, for both he and they are creatures.
Unhappy are they, and the more for that their hurt is from thinking
against Christ; for they have fallen from the truth, and are greater
traitors than the Jews in denying the Christ, and they wallow συγκυλίονται, vid. Orat. i. 23. ii. 1 init.; Decr. 9
fin.; Gent. 19, c. cf. 2 Pet. ii. 22. with the Gentiles, hateful θεοστυγεῖς, infr. Letter 54. 1 fin. as they are to God, worshipping the creature
and many deities. For there is One God, and not many, and One is His
Word, and not many; for the Word is God, and He alone has the Form εἶδος· also
in Gen. xxxii. 30, 31. Sept. [a substitute
for Heb. ‘face.’] vid. Justin Tryph. 126. and
supr. de Syn. 56, n. 6. for the meaning of the word. It was just
now used for ‘kind.’ Athan. says, de Syn. ubi supr.
‘there is but one form of Godhead;’ yet the word is used of
the Son as synonymous with ‘image.’ It would seem as if
there are a certain class of words, all expressive of the One Divine
Substance, which admit of more appropriate application either
ordinarily or under circumstances, to This or That Divine Person who is
also that One Substance. Thus ‘Being’ is more descriptive
of the Father as the πηγὴ
θεότητος, and He is said to be ‘the Being of the Son;’ yet the
Son is really the One Supreme Being also. On the other hand the
words μορφὴ and
εἶδος [on them see Lightfoot, Philipp. p. 128] are rather
descriptive of the Divine Substance in the Person of the Son, and He is
called ‘the form of the Father,’ yet there is but one Form
and Face of Divinity, who is at once Each of Three Persons; while
‘Spirit’ is appropriated to the Third Person, though God is
a Spirit. Thus again S. Hippolytus says ἐκ [τοῦ
πατρὸς]
δύναμις
λόγος, yet shortly
before, after mentioning the Two Persons, he adds, δύναμιν
δὲ μίαν,
contr. Noet. 7 and 11. And thus the word
‘Subsistence,’ ὑπόστασις, which expresses the One Divine Substance, has been found
more appropriate to express that Substance viewed personally. Other
words may be used correlatively of either Father or Son; thus the
Father is the Life of the Son, the Son the Life of the Father; or,
again, the Father is in the Son and the Son in the Father. Others in
common, as ‘the Father’s Godhead is the
Son’s,’ ἡ
πατρικὴ
υἱοῦ
θεότης, as
indeed the word οὐσία itself.
Other words on the contrary express the Substance in This or That
Person only, as ‘Word,’ ‘Image,’
&c. of the Father. Being then such, the Saviour
Himself troubled the Jews with these words, ‘The Father Himself
which hath sent Me, hath borne witness of Me; ye have neither heard His
voice at any time nor seen His Form; and ye have not His Word abiding
in you; for whom He hath sent, Him ye believe not John v. 37..’ Suitably has He joined the
‘Word’ to the ‘Form,’ to shew that the Word of
God is Himself Image and Expression and Form of His Father; and that
the Jews who did not receive Him who spoke to them, thereby did not
receive the Word, which is the Form of God. This too it was that the
Patriarch Jacob having seen, received a blessing from Him and the name
of Israel instead of Jacob, as divine Scripture witnesses, saying,
‘And as he passed by the Form of God, the Sun rose upon him Gen. xxxii.
31,
LXX..’ And This it was who said, ‘He
that hath seen Me hath seen the Father,’ and, ‘I in the
Father and the Father in Me,’ and, ‘I and the Father are
one John xiv. 9, 10; x.
30.;’ for thus God is One, and one the
faith in the Father and Son; for, though the Word be God, the Lord our
God is one Lord; for the Son is proper to that One, and inseparable
according to the propriety and peculiarity of His Essence.