According to Valesius it appears incredible that the
Catholics should have done what Socrates says they did. ‘For
there is nothing more contrary to ecclesiastical discipline than to
communicate with heretics either in the sacraments or in prayer.’
Hence ‘Socrates was probably imposed upon by the aged Auxano, who
fixed upon all the Catholics what was perhaps done by some few
Christians who were less cautious.’ But Socrates’ own
attitude towards the Novatians (cf. Introd. p. x.) shows that the
difference between them and the Catholics (οἱ τῆς
ἐκκλησίας) was
not universally regarded as an absolute schism forbidding communication
even during such times of trial as these described here, which might
certainly have drawn together parties already as near to one another as
the Novatians and Catholics.